A comparative study of poly(glycolic acid) and catgut as suture materials. Histomorphology and mechanical properties

Abstract

The "quality" of poly(glycolic acid) as an absorbable suture material was investigated in comparison with catgut. Tissue reactions to poly(glycolic acid) and plain catgut were examined histomorphologically at different time intervals after implantation in rats, and compared. Four mechanical properties were also examined as relevant quality factors: elastic stiffness, tensile strength, toughness, and percent elongation at rupture of the suture material per se (unknotted). The variation of these properties in poly(glycolic acid) implants was followed since their insertion in the tissues. Histological behavior and mechanical properties appear to be more closely correlated in the case of poly(glycolic acid) than in the case of catgut, as a consequence of a greater regularity of tissue reaction towards the synthetic material. Both tissue reaction and tensile properties variation are independent of size in the case of the braided poly(glycolic acid) sutures examined. Elastic stiffness and tensile strength decrease steadily in time; toughness and ultimate elongation display an increase up to a maximum within one day since implantation, and then decrease.

Comparative study of tissue response to polyglecaprone 25, polyglactin 910 and polytetrafluorethylene suture materials in rats

“…It was used for comparison in the analysis of polyglecaprone 25 suture, showing a good biological reaction, inducing moderate acute inflammatory response in early periods and early fibroblastic and angioblastic proliferation. It also permitted the organization of the fibrous connective tissue around itself at late periods, showing similar behavior as reported by Pavan et al (4). Polyglecaprone 25 showed biological behavior similar to polyglactin 910.…”

Comparing Suture Strengths for Clinical Applications: A Novel In Vitro Study

“…Previous investigations 5,24‐27 of PG sutures showed excellent handling properties, high initial tensile strength, and less tissue reactions. The specific multistranded suture used in this study was PG 910 coated with PG 370.…”

Evaluation of tensile strength of surgical synthetic absorbable suture materials: an in vitro study

“…Previous investigations [17,18] of PGA sutures showed excellent handling properties, high initial tensile strength, and less tissue reaction. PGA suture possesses some properties superior to other materials, in that it does not produce much tissue reaction and has a greater tensile strength than other materials with a similar diameter.…”