A Decision-making Framework for Vegetated Roofing System Selection

Abstract

Design frequently involves a series of tradeoffs to obtain the "optimal" solution to a design problem. Green roofs have many different characteristics based on a variety of variables.Designers typically weigh the impacts of these characteristics in an implicit process based on intuition or past experience. But since vegetated roofing is a relatively complex and comparatively new technology to many practitioners, a rational, explicit method to help organize and rank the tradeoffs made during the design process is useful.This research comprises the creation of a framework diagramming the decision process involved in the selection of vegetated roofing systems. Through a series of expert interviews and case studies, the available knowledge is captured and organized to determine the critical parameters affecting design decisions. A set of six case study projects in North America is analyzed and six critically important evaluative categories are identified: storm water management, energy consumption, acoustics, structure, compliance with regulatory guidelines and governmental incentives, and cost. These six factors are key decision-making parameters in the selection of vegetated roofing systems and they form the basis of this study. They are addressed in the context of a decision support system for green roof designers. A summation of the total importance of the advantages represented by each alternative is used to determine the most feasible green roof system for a particular project. The decision-making framework developed in this dissertation will ultimately be adaptable to digital processing and a computerbased design assistance tool.iii SPECIAL THANKS

Performance of Blue-Green Roofs in Cold Climates: A Scoping Review

“…In Grant and Jones [105], a framework for evaluating green roofs is described, combining green roof characteristics from the FLL guide with the Choosing by Advantages model. A test of the framework could unfortunately not be completed.…”

Adapting green roof irrigation practices for a sustainable future: A review

“…The largest part of the publications involved the A green roof comprises multiple layers that protect the underlying roof and support the 121 vegetation, but the water storage capacity is limited due to physical and economic factors 122 (FLL, 2008). The substrate is the main water storage layer, but water can also be retained in 123 the drainage layer (Theodosiou, 2009) or if present, the water retention layer (WRL), which is 124 a mat from mineral wool or polymeric fibers (1-6.5 cm thick) under or above the drainage 125 layer (Grant, 2007). For extensive green roofs, additional irrigation is often suggested during A c c e p t e d M a n u s c r i p t 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 9 plant establishment as early drought can be very harmful for further plant establishment, 127 performance and survival (Getter & Rowe, 2006;Nagase & Dunnett, 2010;Thuring et al, 128 2010).…”

Urban green roof vegetation assemblage demography, classification and design recommendations

“…People have been planting vegetation on roofs for centuries. The hanging gardens of Babylon can be considered to be ancient examples of such a technology (Grant 2007). Sod roofs have been prolific in Europe for centuries, and plants have been historically reported to be used in roof reinforcement in China and Japan as well (Dunnett and Kingsbury 2008).…”