Functional colloidal nanoparticles capable of converting
between
various energy types are finding an increasing number of applications.
One of the relevant examples concerns light-to-heat-converting colloidal
nanoparticles that may be useful for localized photothermal therapy
of cancers. Unfortunately, quantitative comparison and ranking of
nanoheaters are not straightforward as materials of different compositions
and structures have different photophysical and chemical properties
and may interact differently with the biological environment. In terms
of photophysical properties, the most relevant information to rank
these nanoheaters is the light-to-heat conversion efficiency, which,
along with information on the absorption capacity of the material,
can be used to directly compare materials. In this work, we evaluate
the light-to-heat conversion properties of 17 different nanoheaters
belonging to different groups (plasmonic, semiconductor, lanthanide-doped
nanocrystals, carbon nanocrystals, and metal oxides). We conclude
that the light-to-heat conversion efficiency alone is not meaningful
enough as many materials have similar conversion efficienciesin
the range of 80–99%while they significantly differ
in their extinction coefficient. We therefore constructed their qualitative
ranking based on the external conversion efficiency, which takes into
account the conventionally defined light-to-heat conversion efficiency
and its absorption capacity. This ranking demonstrated the differences
between the samples more meaningfully. Among the studied systems,
the top-ranking materials were black porous silicon and CuS nanocrystals.
These results allow us to select the most favorable materials for
photo-based theranostics and set a new standard in the characterization
of nanoheaters.