“…If the gradients , are linearly pendent, just set , has been obtained by Lin [18] and by Singh [19]; however, their proofs work only if 0 x is a weak Pareto optimal point for (vop) 1 , and not a local weak Pareto optimal point. The flaw is corr ed in Marusciac [20]; s ect ee also the errata corrige of Singh [19], who, however, does not justify his rectification; see also the paper of Wang [21], more specific on this point.…”