A hidden source of innovation? Revisiting the impact of initial vocational training on technological innovation

Abstract

While an increasing number of studies postulate that vocational education and training (VET) activities have a positive impact on the innovative capacity of training companies, empirical evidence on the topic remains contradictory. This study exploits establishment data from a representative survey of German companies to estimate the relationship between firms' participation in initial VET and their innovation outcomes. Our results show that the direct effects of initial VET on technological innovation in small and mediumsized enterprises (SMEs) are on average quite weak. If at all, a training firm's initial VET activities are associated with production innovation activities and not with process innovation. Larger effects can only be observed in case of microenterprises with fewer than ten employees. In these firms, initial VET is associated with a higher probability of (local) new-to-market product innovation if it is accompanied by changes in organizational processes that support individual learning and knowledge creation. We conclude from this finding that the knowledge diffusion function of the VET system primarily holds relevance for the smallest of the training companies and that initial VET is only positively related to technological innovation when it goes along with organizational learning in the training company.

From provider to partner? Main elements of the relationship between schools and small‐ and medium‐sized firms in vocational education work placements in the Basque and Navarre regions (Spain)

“…Even though the reception of apprentices does not need to have a direct impact on technical or organizational improvements strictly speaking (Hernández et al, 2019;Matthies et al, 2023), apprenticeships appear to be an inherent aspect in the German-type incremental innovation model (Euler, 2013). As Rupietta et al (2021, p. 8) recently pointed out in the Swiss case: the continuous review of training curricula has the effect that the theoretical skills that apprentices learn in vocational schools and intercompany training centres are continuously up to date.…”

Development of the Rendang Industrial Innovation System in Payakumbuh City

“…Training for micro, small and medium enterprises (MSMEs) has several benefits for innovation. First, financial management and accounting system training helps MSME entrepreneurs in making accounting-based financial reports and improving their skills in making financial reports (Matthies et al, 2023). Second, training programs that focus on business and financial management can empower and strengthen MSME business management, leading to increased capabilities in planning, business model innovation, and managerial and financial management (Wyati Saddewisasi et al, 2022).…”

Innovations- und Wachstumspfade junger Unternehmen

“…Im Ergebnis stehen dann häufig kundenindividuelle Lösungen. Gleichzeitig verfügen DUI-Unternehmen aufgrund ihrer Stärken im Bereich des beruflich-praktischen Wissens häufig über eine ausgeprägte anwendungsorientierte Absorptionsfähigkeit(Thomä 2017;Thomä 2018;Matthies et al 2023a;2023b), die sie in die Lage versetzt, neue Technologien von außen, die z.B. bei ihren Zulieferern oder anderen Unternehmen bereits im Einsatz sind, aufzunehmen und nutzbar zu machen -was DUIorientierte Jungunternehmen zu einem wichtigen Träger der Technologiediffusion machen dürfte.…”