Low-cost small-scale (<100 W) electrohydrostatic actuators (EHAs) are not available on the market, largely due to a lack of suitable components. Utilizing plastic 3D printing, a novel inverse shuttle valve has been produced which, when assembled with emerging small-scale hydraulic pumps and cylinders from the radio-controlled hobby industry, forms a low-cost and high-performance miniature EHA. This paper presents experimental test results that characterize such a system and highlight its steady, dynamic, and thermal performance capabilities. The results indicate that the constructed EHA has good hydraulic efficiency downstream of the pump and good dynamic response but is limited by the efficiency of the pump and the associated heat generated from the pump’s losses. The findings presented in this paper validate the use of a 3D printed plastic inverse shuttle valve in the construction of a low-cost miniature EHA system.