Following work of Bugeaud, Corvaja, and Zannier for integers, Ailon and Rudnick prove that for any multiplicatively independent polynomials, a, b ∈ C[x], there is a polynomial h such that for all n, we have gcd(a n − 1, b n − 1) | h We prove a compositional analog of this theorem, namely that if f, g ∈ C[x] are nonconstant compositionally independent polynomials and c(x) ∈ C[x], then there are at most finitely many λ with the property that there is an n such that (x − λ) divides gcd(f •n (x) − c(x), g •n (x) − c(x)).