A model for digital development of SMEs: an interaction-based approach

Abstract

PurposeE-business maturity models have been widely used to guide the process of digital transformation of business. However, these models have been criticized for their predominantly technocentric approach, which is poorly suited for SMEs. The purpose of this paper is to produce a holistic, nonlinear e-business development model for SMEs that takes into account the interactions of the organization in the pursuit of its business objectives.Design/methodology/approachBased on the literature review, this paper proposes a nonlinear digital development model for SMEs that factors in the interactions between digital technologies and organizational processes. The model is applied to three cases using a qualitative research approach.FindingsThe analysis of the cases demonstrates how the model recognizes that SMEs have an agile and flexible operating structure and reduces the role of technology in order to refocus the entrepreneurs on the relationship among business goals, organizational capabilities and communication requirements.Practical implicationsThe proposed model helps the business owners to clarify and better understand what kind of interaction levels exist between the relevant actors in the pursuit of the firm's goals and to identify the best mix of digital and nondigital communication methods to support their work. It also assists policymakers to overcome technological bias when assessing the current state of play of e-business development in the SME universe and formulate actions that support the development of digitally oriented SMEs.Originality/valueThis paper proposes a novel, nonlinear, interaction-based development model for SMEs in order to complement previous technocentric models focusing mainly on a mechanist perspective of e-business maturity models.

The Maturity of Corporate Websites as a Digital Communication Channel in Portuguese SMEs’ Process of Adopting E-Commerce

“…In the Portuguese context, the two regions with most economic capacity in the country, Lisbon and Porto, stand out. It is there where there exist a greater number of more developed firms, confirming the relationship between the maturity of the websites and the organization's performance [36].…”

“…This study is framed in the field of models to measure the maturity of websites. In the general field of assessing the effectiveness of a website, the authors consider the quality of the website to be an important area for research, where what is valued is not the characteristics of the website but its functionalities [36].…”

“…Nonetheless, websites continue to be the firm's main online showcase and are the ideal place on which to carry out transactions, since the adoption of e-commerce is especially relevant in the context of SMEs that have a limited geographic scope [12]. Therefore, the importance of corporate websites as instruments of communication between firms and their stakeholders is evident [35,36].…”

Thrive during a crisis: the role of digital technologies in fostering antifragility in small and medium-sized enterprises

“…The internal context of SMEs is being transformed (Lee 2016 ; Neirotti et al 2019 ). Rosenblat and Stark ( 2016 ) have shown that digital technologies positively influence the employee-employer relationship in terms of autonomy and control, as they bring greater flexibility (Depaoli et al 2020 ). Digital technologies have a direct impact on the work of entrepreneurs and managers, which in turn affects SMEs performance and competitiveness (Corvello et al 2021 ; Secundo et al 2020 ).…”

Digital design and technology and market outreach in rural Zimbabwe

“…The app has allowed Bistrot to expand its customer base by reaching tourists and local people alike. Tourists check Bristrot's reviews on websites like Trip Advisor, resulting in new business opportunities [35].…”