The reaction mechanism and enantioselectivity
of the asymmetric
[2 + 2] cycloaddition between an alkynone (R1) and a cyclic enol silyl
ether (R2) were studied theoretically by the DFT method at the B3LYP-D3(BJ)/6-311G**(CH2Cl2,SMD)//B3LYP-D3(BJ)/def2-SVP(CH2Cl2,SMD) theoretical level. The noncatalytic reaction occurred
via a stepwise mechanism. The first C–C bond was constructed
by coupling two pseudo radical centers generated at the most nucleophilic
C2 atom in the cyclic enol silyl ether and the most electrophilic
terminal Cβ atom in the alkynone, which was responsible
for the regioselectivity of the reaction. The counterion NTf2
– could stabilize the Zn(II) complex by coordinating
to the center metal, forming a high-reactivity hexacoordinate Zn(II)-complex
intermediate. The bulky CF3 group in the NTf2
– ion adjusted the blocking effect of o-iPr in aniline of the ligand toward the reactive site (that is, the
Cβ atom in the alkynone) and induced the si face of the cyclic enol silyl ether to approach the alkynone
from its less hindered re face, achieving a high
enanotioselectivity of products. The Pauli repulsion between the Zn(II)-associated
moiety and cyclic enol silyl ether fragment was the main contributor
to the stereodifference of the two competing pathways in chiral N,N′-dioxide-Zn(II)-catalyzed [2
+ 2] cycloaddition. The unfavorable steric repulsion between the o-iPr group of aniline in the ligand and tert-butyldimethylsilyl (TBS) in the cyclic enol silyl ether
along the re face path translated into a more destabilizing
ΔE
Pauli value, leading to the predominant
cycloaddition product (P-RR) observed in experiments.
Variation of the linkage and chiral backbone could affect the repulsion
among the o-iPr in the ligand, the
counterion NTf2
–, and substrates, leading
to different stereochemical outcomes. These results are in good agreement
with experimental observations.