Phytoplankton in the Arctic Ocean are subject to nitrogen limitation in the summer, however, how severely the nitrogen stress affects phytoplankton physiology remains largely unknown. In the summers of 2015-2018, we examined the distribution of phytoplankton photophysiological properties across two contrasting regions of the Arctic Ocean with distinctly different levels of nitrogen availability in the upper water column. We quantified the extent of nitrogen stress using a highly sensitive fluorescence induction and relaxation system to obtain continuous underway measurements and via discrete sample analyses of phytoplankton physiology, as well as nutrient enrichment incubations. The results revealed vast regions in the Chukchi Sea where phytoplankton photosynthesis was severely nitrogen-stressed. Thereby, the maximum quantum yield of photochemistry in photosystem II showed only a small decrease (12 ± 9%) relative to its nutrient-replete values, while the maximum photosynthetic electron transport rates under saturating irradiance were impaired to a greater extent (40 ± 17%). This phytoplankton photosynthesis response is indicative of a severe nitrogen limitation, which results in dramatic reduction in growth and net primary production rates. Nutrient enrichment incubations also revealed a marked increase in large-size phytoplankton growth (>10 μm) after the nitrogen stress was alleviated, suggesting that the larger cells were more susceptible to nitrogen stress. These results are important for understanding how regional nitrogen fluxes control variability in the primary production and phytoplankton community structure and how these processes might change with rapid climate changes in the Arctic Ocean. Plain Language Summary Nutrient availability is the main bottom-up controls of phytoplankton physiology and growth in the upper ocean. The distribution of nutrient limitation in the global ocean varies greatly in space and time, so phytoplankton responses to this factor are essential for understanding the marine ecosystem. Although nitrogen limitation was previously shown in the Arctic Ocean in the summer, how nitrogen stress affects phytoplankton physiology remains largely unknown. This study investigates, with high spatial resolution, the distribution of phytoplankton physiological status and quantifies the effects of nitrogen stress in the western Arctic Ocean. Our results revealed severe nitrogen limitation in the summer that results in dramatic reduction in growth and net primary production in this region of the ocean. Therefore, alterations in nitrogen fluxes along with climate change in the Arctic Ocean would be important for controlling phytoplankton growth and primary production in this region.