A Multirelational Social Network Analysis of an Online Health Community for Smoking Cessation

Abstract

BackgroundOnline health communities (OHCs) provide a convenient and commonly used way for people to connect around shared health experiences, exchange information, and receive social support. Users often interact with peers via multiple communication methods, forming a multirelational social network. Use of OHCs is common among smokers, but to date, there have been no studies on users’ online interactions via different means of online communications and how such interactions are related to smoking cessation. Such information can be retrieved in multirelational social networks and could be useful in the design and management of OHCs.ObjectiveTo examine the social network structure of an OHC for smoking cessation using a multirelational approach, and to explore links between subnetwork position (ie, centrality) and smoking abstinence.MethodsWe used NetworkX to construct 4 subnetworks based on users’ interactions via blogs, group discussions, message boards, and private messages. We illustrated topological properties of each subnetwork, including its degree distribution, density, and connectedness, and compared similarities among these subnetworks by correlating node centrality and measuring edge overlap. We also investigated coevolution dynamics of this multirelational network by analyzing tie formation sequences across subnetworks. In a subset of users who participated in a randomized, smoking cessation treatment trial, we conducted user profiling based on users’ centralities in the 4 subnetworks and identified user groups using clustering techniques. We further examined 30-day smoking abstinence at 3 months postenrollment in relation to users’ centralities in the 4 subnetworks.ResultsThe 4 subnetworks have different topological characteristics, with message board having the most nodes (36,536) and group discussion having the highest network density (4.35×10−3). Blog and message board subnetworks had the most similar structures with an in-degree correlation of .45, out-degree correlation of .55, and Jaccard coefficient of .23 for edge overlap. A new tie in the group discussion subnetwork had the lowest probability of triggering subsequent ties among the same two users in other subnetworks: 6.33% (54,142/855,893) for 2-tie sequences and 2.13% (18,207/855,893) for 3-tie sequences. Users’ centralities varied across the 4 subnetworks. Among a subset of users enrolled in a randomized trial, those with higher centralities across subnetworks generally had higher abstinence rates, although high centrality in the group discussion subnetwork was not associated with higher abstinence rates.ConclusionsA multirelational approach revealed insights that could not be obtained by analyzing the aggregated network alone, such as the ineffectiveness of group discussions in triggering social ties of other types, the advantage of blogs, message boards, and private messages in leading to subsequent social ties of other types, and the weak connection between one’s centrality in the group discussion subnetwork and smoking abstinence. Thes...

Modelling supply chain adaptation for disruptions: An empirically grounded complex adaptive systems approach

“…Competitors beyond these 2,971 firms are not included in the competition network. The supply and the competition networks among the same set of firms are essentially a multirelational network among these firms (Yang, Chawla, Sun, & Han, : Zhao et al, ), but we treat them as two networks to simplify implementations.…”

A prospective examination of online social network dynamics and smoking cessation

“…BecomeAnEX teaches problem-solving and coping skills to quit smoking, educates users about cessation medications, and facilitates social support through a large online social network. The social network is comprised of thousands of current and former smokers who interact via several asynchronous communication channels (e.g., blogs, group discussions, private messages; [ 30 ]). All user actions are date- and time-stamped and stored in a relational database.…”

“…Online social networks provide an exciting opportunity to revisit the mechanisms through which the formation and evolution of social ties may influence smoking behavior [ 20 , 28 , 29 ]. Information technologies enable and record asynchronous and distributed online social interactions, allowing for the use of social computing approaches to analyze an entire social network and subnetworks into which a user is embedded [ 30 ], and to identify the ties that are formed with other members over time (i.e., structural dynamics of the social network). Evaluating structural dynamics in social networks can improve network growth prediction [ 31 ], more accurately identify central network members [ 32 , 33 ] and sub-communities [ 34 ], and better discriminate functional categories of connected user groups within networks [ 35 ].…”

Discussions of Alcohol Use in an Online Social Network for Smoking Cessation: Analysis of Topics, Sentiment, and Social Network Centrality

“…In other words, ties are based on the flow of information either “toward” or “away from” a user (Krippendorff, ). A user's in‐degree reflects the total number of members the user had been exposed to by reading their posts; out‐degree reflects the total number of members who had read the content posted by the user (Zhao et al., ). The whole network, which was constructed and analyzed with the “NetworkX” package (version 1.11) of Python 2.7.11, consisted of 71,251 users in the community, but our subsequent study focused only on a subsample of 1,084 users who posted about alcohol use.…”