“…In fact, for any t ∈ T, we have t + ∈ T, but there exists t = ∈ T such that t − = − ̸ ∈ T. Nevertheless, (1.1) has very nice closedness in translation for time variables if the time scale is only translated towards the positive direction, because for any t ∈ T, we have t + ∈ T. For another example, consider 2) according to the new concept of periodic time scales from [9], (1.2) is also not a periodic time scales since T has a in mum that equals to with respect to the shift operator δ−. In fact, for any t ∈ T, although δ+( , t) = t ∈ T, there exists t = ∈ T such that δ−( , t ) = t / = / ̸ ∈ T. However, (1.2) also has very nice closedness in shift for time variables if the time scale is only shifted towards the positive direction, because for any t ∈ T, we have δ+( , t) ∈ T. Hence, concepts of periodic time scales from [7,9] were without considering the shift direction of time scales.…”