“…In fact, it is argued (Moradi and Cally, 2008;Moradi et al, 2009) that, at least some of, the inconsistencies in the helioseismic analyses of sunspots (Gizon et al, 2009) are likely due to not taking these modes into account. Numerical MHD simulations are currently used to help us gain an insight into such problems (Crouch and Cally, 2003;Shelyag et al, 2007Shelyag et al, , 2009Shelyag et al, , 2010Parchevsky and Kosovichev, 2007;Cameron et al, 2008;Khomenko et al, 2009;Felipe et al, 2010). A variety of propagating and standing MHD waves (e.g.…”