A process model of peer reactions to team member proactivity

Abstract

Team member proactivity refers to self-starting, future-directed behavior to change a team’s situation or the way a team works. While previous studies have shown that individuals generally benefit from their proactivity, few studies have explored how others in a team experience it. This is important as the way peers perceive team member proactivity could be critical for the initiative to be effective. We conducted a 5-month in-depth study to uncover how peers from three self-managing agile teams react to instances of team member proactivity. Our findings suggest a process model of team member proactivity, in which we show that peers react at two distinct moments during proactive episodes. Depending on its perceived success and whether peers directed their reaction to the proactive employee or at their initiative, peer reactions unfolded in four different pathways: by (1) belittling the proactive team member, (2) criticizing the proactivity initiative, (3) supporting the proactive initiative, or (4) admiring the proactive team member. We explain how and why these reactions are formed by showcasing their cognitive, affective, and behavioral evaluations. Our findings contribute to the proactivity literature, provide a process perspective for understanding how peers perceive proactivity, and present implications for sustaining proactivity in teams.

Big data and IoT adoption in shaping organizational citizenship behavior: The role of innovation organizational predictor in the chemical manufacturing industry

“…Organizations with a stronger inclination toward innovation tend to foster a culture encouraging employees to contribute to tasks, assist colleagues proactively, and elicit a heightened sense of organizational loyalty and commitment (Wang et al, 2023). This linkage indicates an innovative corporate environment's constructive influence on employee behaviors that transcend formal job descriptions (Khan et al, 2020;Mi et al, 2019;Twemlow et al, 2022). The acceptance of H5 underscores the importance of cultivating an organizational culture that values and promotes innovation.…”

“…Leadership that values and promotes innovation sets a tone for OCB by signaling that proactive contributions are valued. Innovations often require cross-functional collaboration (Twemlow et al, 2022). Organizations that facilitate and reward cross-functional teamwork create an environment that encourages employees to engage in collaborative OCB, such as helping colleagues in different departments (Hart et al, 2016).…”

Employee Proactive Personality and Career Growth: The Role of Proactive Behavior and Leader Proactive Personality

“…Second, we used a moderated mediation model to test the moderating effect of a leader’s proactive personality. Previous research has pointed out that the way peers perceive employees’ proactivity could affect the initiative’s ability to be effective [ 55 ]. So future studies could examine the moderating effect of peer reactions, and other influencing factors, such as the proactive personality of peers.…”

The double-edged sword effect of employee personal initiative behavior on coworker relationships: The moderating role of the employee warmth trait

“…Ng et al, 2021;Sun et al, 2021)。 一部分学者认为员工主动行 为具有积极的人际影响, 如增强同事的自主性动 机 、 支 持 行 为 和 工 作 绩 效 等(Bark et al, 2022;Twemlow et al, 2022; 张颖 等, 2022)。另一部分学…”