A proposal for overcoming problems in teaching interviewing skills to medical students

Abstract

The objective of this paper is to draw attention to four features that distinguish the pedagogy of patient interviewing from the teaching of other clinical skills: (a) students are not naïve to the skill to be learned, (b) they encounter role models with a wide variability in interviewing styles, (c) clinical teachers are not usually specialists in the behavioral sciences, including patient interviewing, and (d) the validity of the methods used for assessment of interviewing skills is uncertain. We propose to adjust the teaching of patient interviewing to these features by (a) gaining an insight into the students' views and using these views as a point of departure for discussions of patient interviewing; (b) helping students to understand why different clinicians use different communication styles; (c) providing the clinical tutors with additional training that will help them function as both specialists who share their expertise with the students and facilitators of small-group learning; and (d) using assessment methods that encourage joint deliberation by the learner and the examiner, rather than a judgmental right-wrong dualism by the examiner alone. The teaching approach that we suggest is consistent with current theories of adult learning, and it occurs in an egalitarian rather than a hierarchical environment. Hopefully, students will also adopt such egalitarian attitudes toward patients, thereby reducing the tendency to a paternalistic communication style.

Generation Psy: Student characteristics and academic achievement in a three-year problem-based learning bachelor program

“…Moreover, aspects of personality such as conscientiousness, extraversion, and openness which influenced academic achievement in our study could be used to gain more insight into the profile of the student who plans to enroll. This is in line with the belief that in the selection process, secondary school GPA alone is insufficient for predicting academic achievement (Benbassat & Baumal, 2007). These indicators could be used in university admission policies or for mapping students' (knowledge) level from, or even before, the time students start their university education.…”

Assessing the training needs of medical students in patient information gathering

“…In the absence of the thousands of consultations referred to by experienced clinicians, it seems that roleplay with simulated patients, including structured feedback, is highly valued. Consistent with medical education literature supporting the use of experiential learning and simulated patients as providing safe opportunities to practice [24,25,27,43], students valued role-play with simulated patients over that with peers, but did cite a sense of pressure associated with being observed in group settings. Specific teaching approaches have been developed to manage small group environments [44] but medical faculty need to be supported and trained to deliver this teaching effectively.…”

“…The available evidence supports experiential learning models, with the use of actors as simulated patients, and opportunities for feedback and practice [25][26][27]. Multitudes of studies have shown short-term effects of such approaches on specific learning outcome measures.…”

Learning ethics through everyday problems: informed consent

“…Informed Consent (IC, hereafter) is one of the aspects of professional practice that is generally and widely accepted in Western societies (Kihlbom 2008), although difficulties are still encountered in explaining it from a purely theoretical model (Alderson and Goodey 1998;Benbassat and Baumal 2009). Nevertheless, physicians are required by law and medical ethics to obtain informed consent from their patients before initiating treatment (Appelbaum 2007).…”