A Review of Calibration Transfer Practices and Instrument Differences in Spectroscopy

Abstract

Calibration transfer for use with spectroscopic instruments, particularly for near-infrared, infrared, and Raman analysis, has been the subject of multiple articles, research papers, book chapters, and technical reviews. There has been a myriad of approaches published and claims made for resolving the problems associated with transferring calibrations; however, the capability of attaining identical results over time from two or more instruments using an identical calibration still eludes technologists. Calibration transfer, in a precise definition, refers to a series of analytical approaches or chemometric techniques used to attempt to apply a single spectral database, and the calibration model developed using that database, for two or more instruments, with statistically retained accuracy and precision. Ideally, one would develop a single calibration for any particular application, and move it indiscriminately across instruments and achieve identical analysis or prediction results. There are many technical aspects involved in such precision calibration transfer, related to the measuring instrument reproducibility and repeatability, the reference chemical values used for the calibration, the multivariate mathematics used for calibration, and sample presentation repeatability and reproducibility. Ideally, a multivariate model developed on a single instrument would provide a statistically identical analysis when used on other instruments following transfer. This paper reviews common calibration transfer techniques, mostly related to instrument differences, and the mathematics of the uncertainty between instruments when making spectroscopic measurements of identical samples. It does not specifically address calibration maintenance or reference laboratory differences.

Portable Spectroscopy

“…In some cases using NIR spectroscopy, it is also possible to purchase industry-standard quantitative calibrations and transfer them to a different instrument, 568,569 and calibration transfer methods have been reviewed. 570 Technology-based companies who provide engines to instrument manufacturers can rely on their customer to integrate the product and provide the databases, calibrations, and algorithms required.…”

In Situ Calibration Algorithms for Environmental Sensor Networks: A Review

“…This approach was also used by Laref et al [64]. Such strategies are widely use in the field of spectroscopy [65]. It however requires that the measuring instruments are more or less behaving the same under identical varying conditions, which is not always the case when dealing with low cost sensors.…”

High Throughput Screening Technologies in Biomass Characterization

“…Some challenges remain for further development of these novel spectrometers, including the demonstration of adequate data collection and processing environments, long-term performance stability in real-world applications, the ability to develop useful and robust calibration models for use on these new platforms, and to perform accurate calibration transfer among spectrometers (Workman and Mark, 2013) so that calibration equations developed on a primary instrument can be used on multiple secondary instruments. Nonetheless, it is clear that there has been substantial developing in ultra-portable NIR spectroscopy in recent years, and this development will likely continue.…”