“…Through investigation and analysis, we believe that the debris flow incident on the south bank of the Qian River was also triggered by high-intensity rainfall and earthquakes. Around 4 ka BP, floods extensively occurred in the Wei River and its major tributaries in the middle latitude monsoonal climate zone in China, such as the Jing River, Qishui River, Luo River, and so on (Figures 1a and 6;Huang et al, 2010Huang et al, , 2012Huang et al, , 2017Huang, Pang, Zha, Su, & Jia, 2011a;Huang, Pang, Zha, & Zhou, 2011b;Wang et al, 2011;Zhang, Huang, Pang, Zhou, & Wang, 2015;Zhao, Huang, Pang, Zha, & Yao, 2011). The peaks of these ancient floods were much larger than the modern measured floods, and even the largest flood event since the Holocene (Li et al, 2009b;Wang et al, 2011Wang et al, , 2012Zhao et al, 2011;Zhang et al, 2013Zhang et al, , 2015.…”