“…Nonetheless, considering these computational and experimental findings, a contribution of the sigma bond metathesis pathway is unlikely but possible, and in addition, we cannot rule out other possible outer sphere mechanisms or an FLPlike mechanism involving the labile arm, which was recently reported for a copper pincer complex. 66 In that respect, it is interesting to note that the proposed pathway does not specifically implicate the labile arm, indicating that PN complexes may also be suitable for such transformations. 43,67 Finally, with respect to the resting state and active catalytic species, we also note that during the course of the catalytic reaction, the zinc methyl moiety (denoted X in Figure 4) may be protonated with product (supported by the observation of the proposed complex, PNP tBu *ZnNPhBn, in the equilibrium described above), especially as the concentration of amine or alcohol increases during the reaction.…”