A Tale of Two Cultures: Consumer Reactance and Willingness to Book Fenced Rates

Abstract

Rate fences are integral to the practice of revenue management. Prior research suggests that cross-cultural differences in consumer reaction to rate fences exist but little is known about why this is so. This research employed two experimental studies with consumers from the United States and South Korea to explore the mechanisms underlying cultural differences in consumer reaction to nonphysical and physical rate fences. In Study 1, we found that feelings of reactance mediate the restriction-based nonphysical rate fence-willingness to book relationship for highly individualistic cultures, but not for highly collectivist cultures. Study 2’s findings suggest that consumers from low-context cultures favor product-based, over service-based, physical rate fences, while consumers from high-context cultures are unlikely to react differently to product-based, and service-based, physical rate fences. Together, the findings of Study 1 and Study 2 provide tourism managers a framework within which geolocation-based pricing strategies, and associated rate fences, can be evaluated.

How individualism–collectivism influences consumer responses to the sharing economy: Consociality and promotional type

“…On the contrary, people in individualist cultures exhibit greater variance in reactions to interpersonal interactions, as compared to those in collective cultures, who hold consensus expectations of their roles and responsibilities in social interactions (Triandis, ; Triandis et al, ). Individualistic consumers also demonstrate more variance in reactions to specific nuances of pricing due to their relatively low‐context nature (i.e., H. Chen, Bolton, Ng, Lee, & Wang, ; Mattila & Patterson, ; Song, Noone & Mattila, ). Specially, attitudes towards certain incentives of people in individualistic cultures should be contingent on how much their needs for social interactions are fulfilled or primed.…”

Healthy Taste of High Status: Signaling Status at Restaurants

“…It is expected that a lack of freedom of choice erases the status-signaling value of healthy offerings, thereby suppressing satisfaction with such choices. As the effect is hypothesized to hold in individualistic cultures, the study is conducted in the United States in line with previous research (Kim & Markus, 1999;Miller, Das, & Chakravarthy, 2011;Song, Noone, & Mattila, 2018).…”

How Do Group Size and Group Familiarity Influence Tourist Satisfaction? The Mediating Role of Perceived Value

“…Then, we used two scenario-based experiment studies to test the proposed hypotheses. Since the experimental method would improve internal validity by controlling potential confounding variables better, it has been considered as a good supplement to recall surveys (e.g., Shin et al 2019; M. Song, Noone, and Mattila 2018).…”