A tale of two frames: Exploring the role of framing in the use discontinuance of volitionally adopted technology

Abstract

The discontinuance of volitional IS (i.e., information systems adopted, used and discontinued at will) has recently attracted remarkable attention from academics and practitioners alike. However, most research to date has been ahistorical. Ignoring the temporal progression can be problematic when the phenomenon under investigation is dynamic and evolving. To balance this, we adopt a stage modelling approach to understand the process ending with the technology use being discontinued by users of a popular crowdsourcing platform. Two questions guided our investigation: (1) Why do users discontinue using an IS they have volitionally adopted and used? (2) How does IS discontinuance occur over time in such context? We develop a stage model demonstrating that five stages are critical in understanding IS discontinuance: IS framing, goal pursuit, frame disruption, dormancy and quitting, after which possible switching denotes a new cycle. Furthermore, we identify two frames that help us understand why different users interpret and evaluate the technology differently – namely, the gain frame and the hedonic frame. On one hand, a gain frame is linked to the goal of improving one's resources and thus directs the user's attention to the technology's instrumental value. On the other hand, a hedonic frame is linked to the goal of having fun and thus directs the user's attention to the technology's enjoyment value. But, most importantly, we show that the technology's use lifecycle as a whole from initial use to discontinuance is shaped and guided by the user's dominant frame. Our insights elicit a number of important theoretical and practical implications.

Understanding online assessment continuance intention and individual performance by integrating task technology fit and expectancy confirmation theory

“…Therefore, it is essential to train users to use new technology and inform them about the usefulness of using a new will to continue using it. Many industrial reports mentioned that there is a high rate of discontinuance of using technology after using it such as mobile applications and new emerging technology, after using it for a short time ([ 65 , [66] , [67] , [68] ]), which needs more studies to find out the rationale of discontinuance of using new technology.…”

Utopian or dystopian? The portrayal of the metaverse in popular news on social media

“…In the whole lifecycle of technology, frames that people refer to have a robust association with their final choices on accepting or refusing this technology [ 43 ]. In their study of discontinuance of volitional information system (IS), they identified two frames – the hedonic frame and the gain frame.…”

Game affordance, gamer orientation, and in‐game purchases: A hedonic–instrumental framework

“…According to self‐determination theory, both hedonic and instrumental rationales determine an individual's attitudes and behaviour (Chiu et al, 2014; Chu et al, 2015; Soliman & Tuunainen, 2021). Drawing on the instrumental–hedonic framework, gamer orientation can be classified into instrumental and hedonic orientations.…”