Performance-related specifications base pay rates on tests that measure and predict the performance of the mixture. This study evaluated several methods for predicting the rutting resistance of asphalt mixtures. The mixtures and field performance data came from the National Center for Asphalt Technology test track. The pavement sections evaluated were part of an experiment that focused on warm-mix asphalt, high-content reclaimed asphalt pavement (50%), and a combination of the two. One method involved using the dynamic moduli of the mixtures in confined and unconfined conditions. The ranking of the mixtures predicted from both conditions was good compared with the observed ranking from the track but was more reasonable with the confined data. These predictions were compared with common current tests such as the asphalt pavement analyzer and the Hamburg wheel tracker tests. From the ranking of rut depths, these tests did not appear able to distinguish subtler changes to material properties needed for a performance-related specification. Another method employed a viscoplastic shift model implemented within the layered viscoelastic continuum damage program to predict the rut depth. The predicted rut depths were biased 2.5 mm higher than those measured in the field when all three layers (175 mm) of asphalt were used to predict the rut depth, but the ranking matched the field quite well. The results from the top two layers (100 mm) of asphalt were less biased but were more variable than the three-layer results. The results suggest that all pavement layers should be evaluated for predicting rut depths, not just the top two layers.The pavement industry in the United States wants to improve the quality of pavement construction and extend pavement life for new and rehabilitated pavements. One way to increase the quality of asphalt mixtures is to use performance-related specifications, for which the payment adjustment factor is based on measured properties that correlate well with the performance of a mixture instead of surrogate factors such as maximum specific gravity and percent compaction. Measured properties, such as asphalt content, flow number, and lab rut depths, provide possible measurements for correlating to the field performance. Test tracks, such as the National Center for Asphalt Technology (NCAT) pavement test track, provide researchers and state highway agencies with performance data for comparing with candidate properties.The NCAT pavement sections evaluated in this study are part of an experiment that focuses on mixtures with high-content (50%) reclaimed asphalt pavement (RAP), warm-mix asphalt (WMA) technologies, and the interaction of RAP and WMA. The test track pavements used for this study exhibited no apparent cracking during the test cycle, but rutting was observed. The mixtures are characterized for their stiffness and rutting resistance by use of the dynamic modulus (|E*|) test and the triaxial stress sweep (TSS) test, respectively. The TSS test is used to characterize a viscoplastic (VP) material...