Protonation of some cluster complexes with face-capping arene ligands has been studied. The complexes [(CpCo) 3 (µ 3 -η 2 :η 2 :η 2 -arene)] [arene ) isopropylbenzene (1a), 1,4-diethylbenzene (1b), 1,2-diphenylethane (1c), 1,1-diphenylethane (1d)] are protonated at the metal clusters to afford the hydrido cluster cations [(µ 3 -H)(CpCo) 3 (µ 3 -η 2 :η 2 :η 2 -arene)] + (3a-d). The crystal structure of 3d[CF 3 COO] -‚H 2 O has been determined. In marked contrast, derivatives with µ 3 -arenes bearing unsaturated substituents [arene ) R-methylstyrene (2a), β-methylstyrene (2b), p-methoxystyrene (2c)] take up a proton at the β-carbon atom of the side chain to give the novel metal cluster stabilized benzyl cations [(CpCo -c). On attempted crystallization as a tetrafluoroborate, the derivative 4a with a protonated R-methylstyrene ligand is converted to the paramagnetic [(CpCo) 3 {µ 3 -η 2 :η 2 :η 2 -(R-methylstyrene)}] + (2a + ), the crystal structure of which is reported. The different sites of protonation for 1 and 2 are explained by an extended Hu ¨ckel (EH) MO study, using both charge and overlap control arguments. The paramagnetic cation was studied, and its geometry found to agree very well with the experimentally determined structure described for 2a + , suggesting that it is indeed this the species being observed. A detailed analysis of the geometrical preferences of the protonation products 4 was carried out, using EH and density functional methods. A slipped eclipsed arrangement of a nonplanar η 7 -benzyl ligand on top of the Co 3 cluster with the side chain bent away appears to be energetically favored over a staggered substituted benzene.