Abductive reasoning and qualitative research

Abstract

Abduction, deduction and induction describe forms of reasoning. Deduction and induction are discussed in the nursing literature. However, abduction has been largely neglected by nurse scholars. In this paper it is proposed that abduction may play a part in qualitative data analysis - specifically, in the identification of themes, codes, and categories. Abduction is not, in research, restricted to or associated with any particular methodology. Nevertheless, situating abduction in qualitative research facilitates the identification of three interlinked issues. First, it is suggested that abductively derived claims require support from deductive and inductively sourced evidence if they are to 'hold' and, yet, in qualitative research this is clearly problematic. Second, difficulties in choosing between alternative plausible hypotheses (i.e. concerning theme, code, and category description) are explored through an examination of the 'generality problem'. Third, the role of background and auxiliary theories in adjudicating between hypothesis options is discussed. It is argued that if qualitative researchers utilize abductive inference in the manner suggested, then the peculiarly fallible nature of abduction must be acknowledged and, in consequence, the action guiding potential of qualitative research findings is compromised.

Theme development in qualitative content analysis and thematic analysis

“…[79] An important element of such a precise description is induction, deduction and abduction processes applied to identify themes and an account of how they give a thoughtful response to the study question. [80,81] As suggested, ensuring the development of high quality…”

Perceptions of Italian student nurses of the concept of professional respect during their clinical practice learning experience

“…After this first cycle coding (Salda na, 2013), in the second cycle coding, two researchers involved in the study repeated reading, reflecting, and validation of codes and categories, moving forwards and backwards between the growing categories and the text. Subsequently, two overarching interlinked themes became evident through a process of abductive analysis (Lipscomb, 2012). Throughout the whole analysis process, the authors compared and discussed the meaning of preliminary codes and categories until consensus was reached.…”

General practitioners' perspectives on the management of gout: a qualitative study

“…The information was audiotaped and transcribed in full after removal of any identifying information. Later, the data were coded on a line-by-line basis using paper and highlighter and analysed using thematic analysis and an abductive approach to describe and explain key concepts that arose from the data 8. Analysis was then performed between different categories and overarching themes were identified.…”