Elucidating the nature, strength,
and siting of acid sites in zeolites
is fundamental to fathom their reactivity and catalytic behavior.
Despite decades of research, this endeavor remains a major challenge.
Trimethylphosphine oxide (TMPO) has been proposed as a reliable probe
molecule to study the acid properties of solid acid catalysts, allowing
the identification of distinct Brønsted and Lewis acid sites
and the assessment of Brønsted acid strengths. Recently, doubts
have been raised regarding the assignment of the 31P NMR
resonances of TMPO-loaded zeolites. Here, it is shown that a judicious
control of TMPO loading combined with two-dimensional 1H–31P HETCOR solid-state NMR, DFT, and ab initio
molecular dynamics (AIMD)-based computational modeling provides an
unprecedented atomistic description of the host–guest and guest–guest
interactions of TMPO molecules confined within HZSM-5 molecular-sized
voids. 31P NMR resonances usually assigned to TMPO molecules
interacting with Brønsted sites of different acid strength arise
instead from both changes in the probe molecule confinement effects
at ZSM-5 channel system and the formation of protonated TMPO dimers.
Moreover, DFT/AIMD shows that the 1H and 31P
NMR chemical shifts strongly depend on the siting of the framework
aluminum atoms. This work overhauls the current interpretation of
NMR spectra, raising important concerns about the widely accepted
use of probe molecules for studying acid sites in zeolites.