Integrative and conjugative elements (ICEs) are chromosomally encoded mobile genetic elements that can transfer DNA between bacterial strains. Recently, as part of efforts to determine hypothetical gene functions, we have discovered an important regulatory module encoded on an ICE known as TnSmu1 on the Streptococcus mutans chromosome. The regulatory module consists of a cI-like repressor with a helix-turn-helix DNA binding domain immRSmu (immunity repressor) and a metalloprotease immASmu (anti-repressor). It is not possible to create an in-frame deletion mutant of immRSmu and repression of immRSmu with CRISPRi causes substantial cell defects. We used a bypass of essentiality (BoE) screen to discover genes that allow deletion of the regulatory module. This revealed that conjugation genes, located within TnSmu1, can restore the viability of an immRSmu mutant. Deletion of immRSmu also leads to production of a circular intermediate form of TnSmu1, that is also inducible by the genotoxic agent mitomycin C. To gain further insights into potential regulation of TnSmu1 by ImmRSmu and broader effects on S. mutans UA159 physiology we used CRISPRi and RNA-seq. Strongly induced genes included all the TnSmu1 mobile element, genes involved in amino acid metabolism, transport systems, and a Type I-C CRISPR-Cas system. Lastly, bioinformatic analysis shows that the TnSmu1 mobile element and its associated genes are well distributed across S. mutans isolates. Taken together, our results show that activation of TnSmu1 is controlled by the immRASmu module, and that activation is deleterious to S. mutans, highlighting the complex interplay between mobile elements and their host.