The recent advancement in LED technology led many incubator manufacturers and research labs to switch to these more efficient, yet spectrally restricted, light sources. Potential effects of commercially available broad range "white" light systems on phytoplankton growth, productivity, light absorption spectra, and cellular composition have not yet been characterized but could affect our interpretation of lab-based projections on responses to environmental changes. In this study, we investigated such effects using cultures of Prochlorococcus marinus, Synechococcus sp., and Thalassiosira weissflogii grown under three different commercially available LED lights as well as one fluorescent growth light. Photosynthetically active radiation was equal for each species, while photosynthetically usable radiation differed among the combinations of species and treatments. Growth rate was unaffected across species, yet all species displayed changes in cellular carbon, nitrogen, and chlorophyll a quotas as a direct response to the different light spectra. 14 C-based primary productivity was also affected in P. marinus and T. weissflogii. Analysis of pigment ratios and photophysiological data indicated changes in the photoacclimation state between different light environments. The results of this study show that these species undergo changes in underlying cellular metabolism which in turn affect cellular composition while keeping specific growth constant. The data presented here illustrate ecophysiological responses of differently pigmented species when grown under different artificial growth light spectra. These cellular acclimation responses should be considered when designing laboratory-based incubation experiments, especially when comparing responses to specific changes in environmental conditions, or when implementing physiological parameters, derived from laboratory experiments, into numerical models.