Adequately reflecting the severity of tropical cyclones using the new Tropical Cyclone Severity Scale

Abstract

For decades, meteorologists and governments have been warning communities in coastal areas for an imminent tropical cyclone (TC) using the Saffir-Simpson Hurricane Wind Scale (SSHWS). The SSHWS categorizes a TC based on its maximum wind speed, and is used in defining evacuation strategies and humanitarian response. However, the SSHWS considers only the wind hazard of a TC, whereas a TC can also cause severe conditions through its high storm surges and extreme rainfall, triggering coastal and inland flooding. Consequently, the SSHWS fails to mirror the TC’s total severity. This becomes evident when looking at past events such as Hurricane Harvey (2017), which was classified as a Tropical Storm while it caused widespread flooding in the Houston (TX) area, with precipitation totals exceeding 1.5 m. Without including storm surge and rainfall information, adequate risk communication with the SSHWS can be challenging, as the public can (mistakenly) perceive a low-category TC as a low-risk TC. To overcome this, we propose the new Tropical Cyclone Severity Scale (TCSS) that includes all three major TC hazards in its classification. The new scale preserves the categorization as used in the SSHWS, to maintain familiarity amongst the general public. In addition, we extend the scale with a Category 6, to support communication about the most extreme TCs with multiple hazards. The TCSS is designed to be applied on a local-scale, hereby supporting local-scale risk communication efforts and evacuation strategies prior to a TC landfall. The scale can be used for risk communication on both the total TC risk and on the categories of the separate hazards, which can be valuable especially in cases when one hazard is the predominant risk factor, such as excess rainfall triggering flooding.

Tropical Cyclone Impact and Forest Resilience in the Southwestern Pacific

“…These high intensity winds (>75 m/s) resulted on average in a reduction in NDVI greater than 40%. While this breakpoint relies only on a few points, it feeds the debate about updating TC intensity scales to better fit increasing TC intensity (e.g., [27,28]). Indeed, such extremely intense TCs occurred during the last decade and may reflect the possible intensification of these disturbances under human-induced global warming (e.g., [10,29]).…”

A Generalized Natural Hazard Risk Modelling Framework for Infrastructure Failure Cascades

“…Ample documentation of the event permits result validation and provides a reality check on quality and information content of the developed model. Further, Michael's severity was dominated by strong winds and storm surge as opposed to torrential rainfalls [61]. The hazard can therefore be approximated by modelling only its wind-field, lending itself as an illustrative, yet simple enough example.…”

Simulated Changes in Tropical Cyclone Size, Accumulated Cyclone Energy and Power Dissipation Index in a Warmer Climate

“…While the Saffir-Simpson category scale is routinely used to communicate to the public the imminent danger posed by tropical cyclones, more comprehensive alternative scales have been proposed but not widely adopted [26][27][28]. While interpreted by the impact of selected damage types, the Saffir-Simpson scale is actually defined by 1 min average peak near surface wind exceedances over fixed thresholds.…”