Preclinical studies regarding the potential of liver X receptor (LXR) agonists to inhibit macrophage foam cell formation and the development of atherosclerotic lesions are generally executed in mice fed with Western-type diets enriched in cholesterol and fat. Here, we investigated whether LXR agonism remains anti-atherogenic under dietary conditions with a low basal hepatic lipogenesis rate. Hereto, atherosclerosis-susceptible male apolipoprotein E knockout mice were fed a low-fat diet with or without 10 mg/kg/day LXR agonist T0901317 supplementation for 8 weeks. Importantly, T0901317 significantly stimulated atherosclerosis susceptibility, despite an associated increase in the macrophage gene expression levels of cholesterol efflux transporters ABCA1 and ABCG1. The pro-atherogenic effect of T0901317 coincided with exacerbated hypercholesterolemia, hypertriglyceridemia, and a significant rise in hepatic triglyceride stores and macrophage numbers. Furthermore, T0901317-treated mice exhibited elevated plasma MCP-1 levels and monocytosis. In conclusion, these findings highlight that the pro-atherogenic hepatic effects of LXR agonism are dominant over the anti-atherogenic effects in macrophages in determining the overall atherosclerosis outcome under low-fat diet feeding conditions. A low-fat diet experimental setting, as compared to the commonly used high-fat-diet-based preclinical setup, thus appears more sensitive in uncovering the potential relevance of the off-target liver effects of novel anti-atherogenic therapeutic approaches that target macrophage LXR.