After the Nicaraguan Non‐Payment Crisis: Alternatives to Microfinance Narcissism

Abstract

This article argues against ‘microfinance narcissism’ and calls for a re‐politicization of the microfinance paradigm. The dominant verdict on microcredit has undergone a damning transformation, from ‘magic bullet for poverty reduction’ to ‘cause of suicide’. Nowadays, both radical critics and mainstream voices deplore microcredit's negative impact on micro‐entrepreneurs. They argue for a reorientation where credit is targeted at established small and medium‐sized enterprises, particularly in rural areas. The crisis in microfinance worldwide, including burgeoning protests, are viewed as proof of the commercial derailment and/or misplaced faith in microfinance's positive social and economic impact on the poor. This article engages with this debate through a study of the Nicaraguan micro‐finance crisis. It challenges existing analyses that pin the crisis on agricultural over‐indebtedness, lack of due diligence, or Sandinista populist politics. Illustrating the dangers of neglecting the diverse nature of microfinance, it reveals the paradoxical outcomes of the crisis: a refocus on the urban at the expense of agricultural credit for small and medium enterprises and a consolidation of the power of national processing elites. Nicaragua's Non‐Payment Movement is also shown to be both a product of elite manipulation and an expression of legitimate resistance to an industry that turns a blind eye to the manner in which markets and politics constrain clients’ potential.

Comparative projects and the limits of choice: ethnography and microfinance in India and Paraguay

“…How then to proceed with a study of these two cases? While Latin America has previously been at the forefront of commercial microfinance (Bastiaensen et al 2013), there has been a turn back to village banking models in recent years in Paraguay. Simultaneously, despite the early dominance of non-profit group-based lending in South Asia, 2 commercial microfinance has exploded in India (c.f.…”

“…David Graeber's widely popular Debt: The First 5,000 Years, for instance, makes prolific and plural use of comparative methods but without explicitly thematizing comparison on its own terms. 4 Development practitioners have also begun qualifying the extent to which global microfinance models replace existing credit services (Bastiaensen et al 2013;Wagner 2012). However, the discourse around empowerment through financial literacy and moves to seek out and reward "best practices" within the industry combine to create something like a global standard, even if it is aspirational for many organizations (cf.…”

Microfinance and Ecosystems Conservation - How Green Microfinance Interacts with Socio-Ecological Systems - Lessons from Proyecto Cambio in Nicaragua and Guatemala

“…Nicaragua has the second highest deforestation rate among the Central American countries ( However the national MF sector was hit by one of the hardest MF crisis Bastiaensen et. al.…”

Who borrows to accumulate assets? Class, gender and indebtedness in Ecuador’s credit market

“…While the explosion in the number of microfinance institutions (MFIs) throughout the region has undoubtedly increased access to credit, there is concern that the poor may be underrepresented in this expansion, as noted in repeated calls to further deepen outreach efforts (Peck and Miller, 2006;De la Torre, Ize and Schmukler, 2011). At the same time, recent microcredit crises in developing countries have sparked concern that the expansion of microfinance has led to over-indebtedness, particularly among the poor (Schicks, 2013a;Bastiaensen and others, 2013). Figueroa (2011) argues that as long as wealth inequality in Latin America remains high, the region will continue to be subject to a three-tier financial structure in which the poor pay more for access to credit than the rich.…”