Aggregate Economy Risk and Company Failure: An Examination of UK Quoted Firms

Abstract

Considerable attention has been directed in the recent finance and economics literature to issues concerning the effects on company failure risk of changes in the macroeconomic environment. This paper examines the accounting ratio-based and macroeconomic determinants of insolvency exit of UK large industrials during the early 1990s with a view to improve understanding of company failure risk. Failure determinants are revealed from estimates based on a cross-section of 369 quoted firms, which is followed by an assessment of predictive performance based on a series of time-to-failure-specific logit functions, as is typical in the literature. Within the traditional for cross-sectional data studies framework, a more complete model of failure risk is developed by adding to a set of traditional financial statement-based inputs, the two variables capturing aggregate economy risk -one-year lagged, unanticipated changes in the nominal interest rate and in the real exchange rate. Alternative estimates of prediction error are obtained, first, by analytically adjusting the apparent error rate for the downward bias and, second, by generating holdout predictions. More complete, augmented with the two macroeconomic variables models demonstrate improved out-ofestimation-sample classificatory accuracy at risk horizons ranging from one to four years prior to failure, with the results being quite robust across a wide range of cut-off probability values, for both failing and non-failed firms.Although in terms of the individual ratio significance and overall predictive accuracy, the findings of the present study may not be directly comparable with the evidence from prior research due to differing data sets and model specifications, the results are intuitively appealing. First, the results affirm the important explanatory role of liquidity, gearing, and profitability in the company failure process. Second, the findings for the failure probability appear to demonstrate that shocks from unanticipated changes in interest and exchange rates may matter as much as the underlying changes in firm-specific characteristics of liquidity, gearing, and profitability. Obtained empirical determinants suggest that during the 1990s recession, shifts in the real exchange rate and rises in the nominal interest rate, were associated with a higher propensity of industrial company to exit via insolvency, thus indicating links to a loss in competitiveness and to the effects of high gearing. The results provide policy implications for reducing the company sector vulnerability to financial distress and failure while highlighting that changes in macroeconomic conditions should be an important ingredient of possible extensions of company failure prediction models.JEL Codes: G33

Multifactor Consumption Based Asset Pricing Models Using the US Stock Market as a Reference: Evidence from a Panel of Developed Economies

“…A secondary feature of the crisis relates to corporate failure and it can be shown for the UK (Hunter and Isachenkova, 2006) and for other economies (Hunter and Isachenkova, 2001), that a key aspect of corporate failure is liquidity. In terms of macro variables, high nominal interest rates and real exchange rates in the case of the UK are a key failure predictor more than one year in advance.…”

“…Hence, the incapacity of monetary authorities and the Monetary Policy Committee of the Bank of England to focus what on was happening in the …nancial markets and become …xated on in ‡ation was to have severe consequences for corporate failure once the crises started to bite. The collapse in asset values induces increased problems with debt that are invidiously linked with the Basel II and the capacity of corporations to …nd liquidity in an already di¢ cult market when debt to equity ratios are moving in the wrong direction (Hunter and Isachenkova, 2006). This feeds into the …nal factor in the pricing of the assets, the fundamental relationship between stock performance and growth in the economy as captured by the consumption term in the multifactor model.…”

Macroeconomic Determinants of Financial Distress in Turkey: An Econometric Analysis

“…It is expected to have a positive relationship between new firm establishment and financial distress in line with the literature [i] . Goudie and Meeks (1991), Hunter and Isachenkova (2006), Bhattacharjee et al (2009) use exchange rate instability in their studies as a macroeconomic factor affecting financial distress. Salman et al (2011) use exports as a measure of the openness of the economy.…”

Minsky’s financial instability hypothesis, information asymmetry and accounting information: the UK financial crises of 1866 and 1987

“…This and other measures of the Financial Services Act 1986 and related Acts effectively enabled financial institutions to cease specialization and become financial conglomerates and offer a full range of financial services. For a discussion of the implications of these changes see Ingham and Thompson (1993). 19.…”