‘Allowed into a Man's World’ Meanings of Work–Life Balance: Perspectives of Women Civil Engineers as ‘Minority’ Workers in Construction

Abstract

This article discusses how women working as civil engineers within the UK construction industry perceive work-life balance and considers strategies they use to achieve this. The findings are presented of a qualitative research project that explored the experiences of women in this role, focusing on the subcultural context of a profession that is dominated by the values of presenteeism and infinite availability. A feminist poststructuralist framework is used to analyse how women negotiate their personal and professional time and the extent to which their other roles as carers and nurturers unsettle male work practices in this highly gendered profession. There are gradually increasing numbers of women in professional construction roles and their success appears to depend on being able to fit in to the dominant masculine culture of long working hours and the male pub gathering. Despite an increased presence, women's minority status in construction continues to challenge their professional identity and this is central to the conflict many face between the dual roles of corporate worker and private non-work person.

Surf ’s Up: Work, Life, Balance and Brand in a New Age Capitalist Organization

“…Globalization, it is claimed, brings in its wake increased competition among businesses, with a concomitant rise in working hours and intensity. Although evidence of an absolute increase in working hours is contestable (Warhurst et al, 2008), it would appear that for managers at least long hours are a norm, particularly in industries with a culture of presenteeism (Watts, 2009). More generally, weakened trade unions, deregulation, reorganization, efficiency drives and the emergence of the 24/7 workplace combine with technological innovation to increase the intensity, if not the absolute hours, of work, raising further concerns over the achievement of balance (Lewis et al, 2007).…”

Reasons for job separations in a cohort of workers with psychiatric disabilities

“…This may not be the case for workers with disabilities, who may need or prefer the flexibility of nonpermanent positions [40]. A similar rationale may apply to our finding of higher voluntary separation likelihood for jobs in the structural (construction) industries, occupations known for their required "presenteeism" and "infinite availability" [41], which may be a poor match for the needs and stamina of some workers with psychiatric disabilities [42], such as veterans who may have co-occurring physical injuries and impairments [43].…”

‘My home is my castle’. The Norwegian home in times of paid migrant domestic labour

“…In addition to managing unpaid domestic labour in their own dwelling, women have traditionally filled domestic jobs of cleaning, caring and cooking -jobs that are typically poorly regulated and poorly paid (Gregson and Lowe 1994). As more women entered the labour force in the 20th century, leaving both men and the public sector with increased responsibility for domestic tasks, the gender difference in these roles to some extent became less distinct (Gullikstad et al 2016;Tronto 2002;Watts 2007). At the same time, women's increased participation in the labour market has produced a care deficit that neither men nor the public sector have been able or willing to fill, paving the way for the 'feminisation of migration' and 'global care chains' (Gullikstad et al 2016;Hochschild 2001;Isaksen 2010;Lutz 2008Lutz , 2011Triandafyllidou and Marchetti 2015).…”