The essential point of the note by Vayenas and Vernoux is to defend the "sacrificial promoter" mechanism, which involves two oxygen species and has been advocated in numerous papers and monographs by Vayenas et al., against the ignition mechanism suggested by us in two recent papers. [1,2] The basic idea of the "ignition concept" is to explain the huge non-Faradaic effect found in the electrochemical promotion of catalytic (EPOC) ethylene oxidation and many other reaction systems exhibiting an EPOC effect without having to invoke the special oxygen spillover species postulated by Vayenas et al. In their "sacrificial promoter" mechanism, besides regular chemisorbed oxygen, a special oxygen spillover species should exist on Pt/ YSZ (YSZ = yttria-stabilized ZrO 2 ), with particular properties that differ from those of regular chemisorbed oxygen on Pt. [3,4] There is insofar agreement as the identity of chemisorbed oxygen and the spillover species at low coverage/low pressure is accepted, that is, under these conditions, only one oxygen species exists. [5][6][7] In contrast to that, the issue of a special spillover species at high coverage/high pressure remains controversial. In the second last paragraph one can read the following statement about the two-oxygen species mechanism: "This mechanism has been confirmed beyond any reasonable doubt by numerous techniques, e. g. XPS, TPD (temperature-programmed desorption) and temperature-programmed oxidation (TPO)." A strong statement, but if one actually goes into the details of these "proofs", one does not find a single proof which withstands a detailed examination (for more details, see ref. [7]). The O1 s BE at 528.8 eV often cited as evidence for O dÀ with (d % 2) stems from oxygen of YSZ which floats with the applied potential, [7,8] the peak assigned in cyclic voltametry to the spillover species was shown to be caused by Si contamination. [9] How about TPD? Right at the beginning of their note, Vayenas and Vernoux present in Figure 1 O 2 TPD spectra from Pt/YSZ obtained after 18 O 2 adsorption from the gas phase, followed by electrochemical pumping of 16 O from YSZ. Again, the authors are convinced that this figure "leaves little room for any reasonable doubts about the validity of the sacrificial promoter, i. e. two oxygen species mechanism". What one sees in their Figure 1 are two adsorption states as they are common in practically all O 2 adsorption experiments on noble-metal surfaces. The two states arise typically due to energetic interaction of the adsorbed particles which become dominant at high coverage and, in addition, due to different grain orientations on the polycrystalline material. As expected for dissociative chemisorption, one finds isotopic mixing. The amount of mixing varies for the two states but this is no surprise because depending on the distance from the tpb (three-phase boundary) where the spillover species originates, the oxygen coverage . Schematic representation of the ignition mechanism proposed for the electrochemical activation of catal...