Non-graphitic carbons (NGCs), such as glass-like carbons, pitch cokes, and activated carbon consist of small graphene layer building stacks arranged in a turbostratic order. Both structure features, including the single graphene sheets as well as the stacks, possess structural disorder, which can be determined using wide-angle X-ray or neutron scattering (WAXS/WANS). Even if WANS data of NGCs have already been extensively reported and evaluated in different studies, there are still open questions with regard to their validation with WAXS, which is usually used for routine characterization. In particular, using WAXS for the damping of the atomic form factor and the limited measured range prevent the analysis of higher-ordered reflections, which are crucial for determining the stack/layer size (La, Lc) and disorder (σ1, σ3) based on the reflection widths. Therefore, in this study, powder WANS was performed on three types of carbon materials (glass-like carbon made out of a phenol-formaldehyde resin (PF-R), a mesophase pitch (MP), and a low softening-point pitch (LSPP)) using a beamline at ILL in Grenoble, providing a small wavelength and thus generating WANS data covering a large range of scattering vectors (0.052 Å−1 < s < 3.76 Å−1). Merging these WANS data with WANS data from previous studies, possessing high resolution in the small s range, on the same materials allowed us to determine both the interlayer and the interlayer structure as accurately as possible. As a main conclusion, we found that the structural disorder of the graphene layers themselves was significantly smaller than previously assumed.