To investigate the paediatric volumetric accuracy for two enteral syringe brands, using commercially available liquid drug formulations, across a range of clinically relevant volumes and physicochemical properties.
Method:In vitro experiment under laboratory conditions. Ten drug formulations were tested for two syringe brands (Baxa, Medicina) using a range of formulation volumes (0.05 to 5 mL) and syringe sizes (1 to 5 mL). The weight of syringes, empty, filled and after expelling liquids were accurately measured and converted into volume, based on the known formulation densities. Ten replications were performed for each combination of drug, syringe and volume. Accuracy of the delivered volume was expressed as a percentage of desired volume, with desired range being within +10% for all replications.
Results:The two brands showed a different type of error, with Baxa demonstrating a slight positive bias (excess average volume delivered) at the smallest volumes tested in each syringe size, while Medicina had poorer precision (greater variability) at the smaller volumes (ANOVA 2-and 3-way interactions all P< 0.005). Using these results we were able to identify a lower limit for volume accuracy for each syringe size and each brand. Of note, the 1mL syringe for both brands was inaccurate below volumes of 0.25 mL. The physicochemical properties of pH (range 2.82 to 7.45), surface tension (30.2 to 86.7 mN/m) and viscosity (2 to 299 mPaS) did not influence error in a discernible pattern.
Conclusion:Volumetric dosing was inaccurate when the smallest volumes were used across all syringe sizes and brands. These volumes reflect those used in clinical practice; thus error could potentially be reduced by manufacturers revising formulation concentrations for certain drugs.3