An Evaluation Matrix to Compare Computer Hydrological Models for Flood Predictions

Abstract

In order to predict and control the impacts of floods in torrents, it is important to verify the simulation accuracy of the most used hydrological models. The performance verification is particularly needed for applications in watersheds with peculiar climatic and geomorphological characteristics, such as the Mediterranean torrents. Moreover, in addition to the accuracy, other factors affect the choice of software by stakeholders (users, modellers, researchers, etc.). This study introduces a “performance matrix”, consisting of several evaluation parameters weighted by stakeholders’ opinions. The aim is to evaluate the accuracy of the flood prediction which is achieved by different models, as well as the pros and cons of software user experience. To this aim, the performances and requisites of four physical-based and conceptual models (HEC-HMS, SWMM, MIKE11 NAM and WEC-FLOOD) have been evaluated, by predicting floods in a midsized Mediterranean watershed (Mèsima torrent, Calabria, Southern Italy). In the case study, HEC-HMS and MIKE 11 NAM were the best computer models (with a weighted score of 4.45 and 4.43, respectively), thanks to their low complexity and computation effort, as well as good user interface and prediction accuracy. However, MIKE11 NAM is not free of charge. SWMM showed a lower prediction accuracy, which put the model in third place of the four models. The performance of WEC-FLOOD, although not being as good as for the other tested models, can be considered overall acceptable in comparison to the other well-consolidated models, considering that WEC-FLOOD is in the early stage of development. Overall, the proposal of the performance matrix for hydrological models may represent a first step in building a more complete evaluation framework of the hydrological and hydraulic commercial models, in order to give indications to allow potential users to make an optimal choice.

Modelling the Event-Based Hydrological Response of Mediterranean Forests to Prescribed Fire and Soil Mulching with Fern Using the Curve Number, Horton and USLE-Family (Universal Soil Loss Equation) Models

“…The hydrological processes in burned soils are very complex, since several factors (weather, fire severity, vegetation cover, soil properties, morphology, and land management) influence the hydrological response of soil [2,4,15]. Computer-based hydrological models are essential tools to better understand and predict the hydrological processes in a costeffective and time-efficient way [16], including in burned soils. However, validation under different environmental conditions is required, to ensure model applicability and reliability for predicting post-fire hydrology [17,18].…”

A paradigm of extreme rainfall pluvial floods in complex urban areas: the flood event of 15 July 2020 in Palermo (Italy)

“…The model belongs to the family of the probability distribution models (PDMs; Moore, 1985), which represent the basin as a series of storages of capacity c. In particular, the TOPDM uses the spatial distribution of the topographic index to derive the probability distribution of the capacity of the considered storages. The model is capable of working at different temporal scales (i.e., from sub-hourly to daily); this makes the TOPDM suitable for simulating runoff and analyzing hydrological processes at the catchment scale, using a daily time step, or for simulating the flood forcing within the small Mediterranean basins, using an hourly or sub-hourly time step (Forestieri et al, 2016).…”

Comparing the Hydrological Response of Forested Headwaters (Unregulated and Regulated with Check Dams) under Mediterranean Semi-Arid Conditions

“…For instance, construction of several check dams in the middle of the last century has avoided disrupting floods with heavy damage to infrastructures and loss of human lives in torrents of Southern Italy [23,24]. In this environment, the peculiar morphological characteristics of catchments (small drainage areas with short length and steep profile of channels), coupled with intrinsic climatic forcing (frequent and intense rainstorms), usually produce heavy flash floods with high erosive power, often causing hydro-geological instability and disruption [25][26][27].…”