Transport is recognized as a major energy consumer and environment pollutant. Recently scholars have paid considerable attention to the evaluation of transport energy and environmental efficiency (EEE). In this paper, the non-radial Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA) model was employed to evaluate EEE on a macro level-i.e., of European road, rail and air sectors. The evaluation was conducted under the joint production framework, which considers energy and non-energy inputs, and desirable and undesirable outputs for the last ten years period. To rank decision-making units and check the aptness of this non-radial DEA model in transport EEE evaluation, the Technique for Order of Preference by Similarity to Ideal Solution (TOPSIS) method has been proposed. An empirical study has been conducted for as many European countries as possible, depending on availability of data. Based on the non-radial DEA model, it could be said that the level of EEE is improving for the road sector, while many evaluated countries have low EEE for the rail transport sector. Additionally, results have indicated that the TOPSIS method is more suitable than the non-radial DEA model in transport EEE evaluation and for identification of best practices.Energies 2019, 12, 2907
The Aim and the Scope of the PaperThe aim of this paper is twofold. The first is to evaluate and analyze the changes of EEE of European road, air, and rail transport sectors, where the methodology for evaluating EEE is based on a non-radial DEA model proposed by Wu et al. [6] for 2006-2008, 2010, 2012, and 2014-2016, using the available data for the European countries which represent DMUs. The second aim of the paper is the introduction of the TOPSIS method in the evaluation of EEE, where the TOPSIS method is used for the ranking of DMUs. The evaluation of transport EEE has been done under the joint production framework, using non-energy inputs (labor and transport assets) and energy input (energy consumption) to produce desirable outputs (volume of passenger and freight transport) and undesirable output (GHG emissions). Aside from other widely used non-radial DEA models such as Slack-based models, Russell measure models, and Directional distance function, in this paper, the non-radial DEA model has been chosen due to its ability to use different non-proportional adjustments, with decision maker specified weights assigned to each efficiency score, and because of its ability to proportionally decrease the amounts of energy inputs and undesirable outputs simultaneously as much as possible [5,6].The main contributions of this study are: (i) a newly systematic literature review in the field of transport EEE evaluation, (ii) a new definition of transport EEE, (iii) the evaluation of EEE with an extended set of used inputs, (iv) the evaluation of EEE of road, air, and rail transport sectors of European countries and their changing tendencies in terms of the EEE, (v) use of non-radial DEA and introduction of the TOPSIS method through DMUs ranking in the evaluation of transport EEE, ...