An examination of student preference for traditional didactic or chunking teaching strategies in an online learning environment

Abstract

This research examined first year undergraduate tertiary student preferences for different online video playback options by comparing a didactic long lecture recording versus a series of topical ‘chunked’ videos of identical learning material in an information literacy unit. Student preference was determined by student unique download choice of streaming video lecture material, cumulative visits and percent completion of viewing of lecture videos. De-identified click-stream data for 1268 university students across two academic years 2016 (n = 647) and 2017 (n = 621) were pooled to examine student preference. The major findings indicated a significant preference for chunk-style videos between 3 and 17 min duration when compared to traditional long-view didactic lecture materials. Results also highlighted an increase in unique views (60%–67%), cumulative visits (54%–67%) and percentage completions (25%) of chunked videos compared to didactic lectures (60 min). Additionally, student total viewing of the unit information influenced the final grade for the unit. Student preference and success were in favour of the smaller chunk-style lectures, which may also improve student attention, assist with time management to complete the materials and increase unit engagement. The overall findings of this research re-enforce the value of student-centric learning design in university education settings.

Blended learning in a biology classroom: Pre‐pandemic insights for post‐pandemic instructional strategies

“…It also involves presenting information in digestible chunks. Evidence supporting this theory includes a study by Humphries and Clark who illustrated that providing didactic information in small chunks (3‐ or 17‐min videos vs. one‐hour didactic lectures) was associated with stronger student preference, increased cumulative use, increased completion of instructional material, and improved student grades [ 42 ]. Based on findings such as these, current guidelines on cognition in education indicate that six to nine minutes is the optimal length for a video in order to sustain audience attention [ 43 ].…”

Learning Theory-Driven Tips for Designing Effective Learning Solutions for the Continuous Education of Community Pharmacists to Enhance Patient-Centered Care—A Qualitative Study

“…Although still frequently used, such passive formats tend to create a disproportion between an extensive amount of provided content and participants’ ability to focus and acquire knowledge, with an attention span of approximately only 10–20 min. For that reason, other forms should be sought in order to minimize the cognitive activity, for example, dividing the content into smaller parts, called “chunking,” can improve focus, learning, and retention of knowledge [ 46 ].…”

From didactic to interactive – enhancing the student experience through innovative approaches

“…• applying the facilitators' learning design approach to transform content into an engaging, studentcentered learning experience (Humphries, et al 2021). • designing scalable online content within the constraints of available time and resources • creating evergreen, sustainable content • breaking down complex content into digestible components (Bradbury, 2016).…”