An integrated process and management tools for ranking multiple emerging threats to animal health

Abstract

Additional Information:• This paper was accepted for publication in the journal Preventive Vet- Del Rio, V., Voller, F., Montibeller, G., Franco, L. A., Sribhashyam, S., Watson, E., Hartley, M., & Gibbens, J.2013. An integrated process and management tools for ranking multiple emerging threats to animal health. Abstract: The UK's Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs supports the use of systematic tools for the prioritisation of known and well defined animal diseases to facilitate long and medium term planning of surveillance and disease control activities. The recognition that emerging events were not covered by the existing disease-specific approaches led to the establishment of the Veterinary Risk Group (VRG), constituted of government officials and supporting structures, the risk management cycle and the emerging threat highlight report (ETHiR), to facilitate the identification, reporting and assessment of emerging threats to UK's animal health. Since its inception in November 2009 to the end of February 2011, the VRG reviewed 111 threats and vulnerabilities (T&V) reported through ETHiR. In July 2010 a decision support system based on multi-criteria-decision-analysis (MCDA) improved ETHiR to allow the systematic prioritisation of emerging T&V. The DSS, known as e-THiR, allows the regular ranking of emerging T&V by calculating a set of measurement indices related to the actual impact, possible impact on public perception, and level of available capabilities associated with every T&V. The systematic characterisation of the processes leading to the assessment of T&V by the VRG has led to a consistent, auditable and transparent approach to the identification and assessment of emerging risks. The use of MCDA to manage a portfolio of emerging risks represents a different and novel application of MCDA in a health related context. This paper describes and discusses the characterisation and management of emerging risks by the VRG since its inception, and results from a pilot application of the e-THiR system to a reduced set of emerging threats.

A cooperative approach to animal disease response activities: Analytical hierarchy process (AHP) and vvIBD in California poultry

“…The application of decision-tree analysis to animal health was explored in the 1980s and 1990s to estimate monetary values of or cash flow associated with action choices involving animal health programs (Elder and Morris, 1986;Ngategize et al, 1986;Parsons et al, 1986;Gillard and Monypenny, 1988;Bennett, 1992). Recently, MCDM approaches have been used for prioritizing diseases affecting animal health (Brookes et al, 2012;Del Rio Vilas et al, 2012;Humblet et al, 2012) and public health (Humblet et al, 2012) and to evaluate animal disease control strategies (van Asseldonk et al, 2005;Mourits and Oude Lansink, 2006;Mourits et al, 2010).…”

D2R2: an evidence‐based decision support tool to aid prioritisation of animal health issues for government funding

“…Since then its ranking reports have informed Defra resource allocation, risk management decisions, including guiding research budget allocation, the selection of diseases for international disease monitoring and informing threat assessment by the VRG (Del Rio Vilas and others 2013). Individual disease reports provide material for Ministerial submissions, impact assessments and cost–benefit analyses and reactive disease briefing.…”

Prioritization of capacities for the elimination of dog-mediated human rabies in the Americas: building the framework

“…Successful application of MCDA models in regular policy contexts have been reported elsewhere, 15 and have shown the benefits of systematic approaches to capacity prioritization. Indirectly, as countries or territories align their evidence needs to the framework requirements, we will be able to assemble a repository of comparable data on process-related indicators across the region, such as response time to outbreaks, is of critical importance for future modeling, operational and policy needs towards the elimination of dog mediated rabies in the Americas.…”