Mechanisms of the gas-phase acyl group transfers, Cl- + R(XY)Cl, involving various acyl
functional groups, >XY with X = C, S, or P and Y = O or S, are investigated theoretically at the MP2/6-31+G* and B3LYP/6-31+G* levels (additionally with extended basis sets of B3LYP/6-311+G(3df,2p)),
and the effects of solvent (ε = 78.5) are calculated with the SCIPCM model at the isodensity level of 0.0004
au. The tetrahedral adducts formed in the carbonyl (RCO) and thiocarbonyl (RCS) group transfers are
either transition states (double-well PES) or intermediates (single- or triple-well PES) depending on R, a stronger
electron acceptor R favoring the intermediate. However, all of the sulfonyl (RSO2) and phosphoryl ((RO)2PO) transfers proceed with trigonal bipyramid (TBP)-type transition states, in contrast to the stepwise mechanism
through TBP-type intermediates for the sulfinyl (RSO) (and sulfonyl transfers between F-) transfers. The
most important factor determining whether an adduct in an acyl-group-transfer reaction is the transition state
or intermediate is the energy gap between the
and
orbitals. The possibility of reacting through an
intermediate is greater for lower
and higher
levels. The backside σ-attack pathway is favored
over the π-attack pathway only when a low-lying
orbital, preferably below the
level, is available.
In general, the results are in good agreement with those of experiments. The solvent effect elevates the barrier
height almost uniformly so that the relative orders of gas-phase activation barriers between different R groups
are maintained in solution.