A comparative study was conducted of composites made with sludge from three different paper mills. Sludges were obtained from a thermomechanical pulp (TMP), a chemico‐TMP (CTMP), and a Kraft mill with a feedstock of primarily black spruce. The primary sludge (PS) and secondary sludge (SS) were mixed at two different ratios (PS:SS = 7:3 and 9:1) and blended with high‐density polyethylene (HDPE) at 20%, 30%, and 40% proportion. The blends were tested using plate–plate geometry before subjection to frequency sweep by oscillation rheometry. The storage modulus (G′), loss modulus (G″), and complex viscosity (η*) increased with increasing paper sludge content. Decreasing the PS:SS ratio from 9:1 to 7:3 decreased G′, G″, and η*. Differential scanning calorimetry showed that sludge addition increased both the melting and crystallization temperature, for a positive effect on crystallinity. Although the behavior of sludge–high‐density polyethylene blends differed from that of traditional wood plastic composite made with wood flour, they obtained G′, G″, and η* values of the same magnitude. © 2018 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J. Appl. Polym. Sci. 2018, 135, 46484.