Application of a Hybrid Multi-Criterion Decision-Making Model for Evaluation and Improvement of Nurses' Job Satisfaction

Abstract

BackgroundThe global shortage and turnover of nurses is a current challenge. Past studies have shown that nurse job satisfaction may ameliorate nurse shortage. Although there are many studies on the criteria influencing nurses' job satisfaction, few have examined the causal relationships and weight of each criterion from a systematic perspective.ObjectiveIdentify the key criteria and causal relationships that affect nurses' job satisfaction, and help nurse leaders identify high-weight, high-impact dimensions and contextualize them for improvement.MethodsThe study developed a hybrid multi-criterion decision-making model, which incorporated the McCloskey/Mueller satisfaction 13-item scale (MMSS-13), and the Decision-Making Trial and Evaluation Laboratory and the Importance-Performance Analysis methods the model was used to analyze key factors of nurse satisfaction and their interrelationships based on the experience of 15 clinical nurse specialists.ResultsIn MMSS-13's dimension level, “satisfaction with work conditions and supervisor support” (C5) had the highest impact, and “satisfaction with salary and benefits” (C1) had the highest weight. In criteria level, “salary” (C11), “flexibility in scheduling time off” (C24), “maternity leave time” (C31), “opportunities for social contact after work” (C41), and “your head nurse or facility manager” (C51) had high influence under their corresponding dimensions. The “benefits package” (C13) was the top criterion with the highest impact on MMSS-13.ConclusionsThis study assessed nurses' job satisfaction from a multidimensional perspective and revealed the causal relationships between the dimensions. It refined the assessment of nurse job satisfaction to help nurse leaders better assess nurse job satisfaction and make strategic improvements. The study found that compensation and benefits had the highest weight in nurses' job satisfaction. Meanwhile, support for family responsibilities and working conditions, and support from supervisors were the cause dimensions of job satisfaction. Among the more detailed criteria, salary, benefits package, maternity leave time, and leadership had a greater impact on nurses' job satisfaction. Nurse leaders should start with these dimensions to achieve efficient improvement of nurses' job satisfaction.

Identifying key mental health and improvement factors in hospital administrators working from home using a DEMATEL-based network analysis model

“…The DEMATEL method is a system structure analysis that analyzes the complex social network structure of problems in the real world using the practical experience of a group of experts ( 22 , 23 ). This method can analyze the interaction between subsystems in a system and visualize it using graph theory, to construct an influence network diagram ( 24–26 ).…”

Evaluation and improvement of workplace vertical violence of nursing interns based on the Importance-Performance Analysis method

“…The Importance-Performance Analysis (IPA) method is used to evaluate the relative importance of various factors in a system or process and to identify areas for improvement. Since then, it has been widely used in the fields of nurses job satisfaction ( 27 , 28 ), shared decision-making ( 29 ), and university-teacher development ( 30 ).…”

Exploration of Factors Influencing Intention to Leave: Indonesian Professional Working in Qatar Case

“…The "pay" survey scores indicate that employees are satisfied with what they are getting fair pay but less satisfied with the chances for salary increases in future, indicating employees are happy with their current financial situation but may have future concerns about future pay, which may impact their employment longevity and career choices. According to research (Liu, et al, 2022) that assessed nurses' job satisfaction in China found that pay and benefits were the most important factors in nurses' job satisfaction. For many expatriates, financial incentives are a key motivator for working abroad due to higher salary packages compared to their home country.…”