The
commercial production from tight oil and gas reservoirs has
been facilitated by the multistage hydraulic fracturing of horizontal
wells. This process typically requires the pumping of large amounts
of slick water into the subsurface, and this could be challenging
in areas with a limited supply of water. Despite the commercial success
of hydraulic fracturing with water, it still faces the problem of
clay swelling and potential contamination of underground water. This
has led to research studies and field applications of liquid or supercritical
carbon dioxide (SC-CO2) fracturing in unconventional oil
and gas resources. Considering that the propagation and characteristics
of these man-made fractures are controlled by the fracturing fluid
and mechanical state of the reservoir, we performed a series of fracturing
experiments on tight sandstones using water and SC-CO2 at
different stress magnitudes. To explore the morphology of the fractures
and quantify their attributes, we proposed a novel full-sample fracture
analysis approach, which is based on microcomputed tomography (CT)
imaging. The results of this study indicate that the breakdown pressure
is a linear function of the minimum principal stress and tensile strength.
We observe that the pattern and geometry of the fractures created
from SC-CO2 fracturing is more complex than those of water
fracturing under the same stress conditions. Our experimental results
also indicate that smaller differential stresses lead to the creation
of more fracture branches and that fracture propagation is significantly
affected by the presence of initial bedding planes. Furthermore, our
quantification of the fracture attributes (based on fracture extraction
and digitization) indicates that SC-CO2 fracturing leads
to the creation of more complex fractures with rougher surfaces than
water fracturing. This experimental study proposes a new full-sample
fracture quantification approach, which can be implemented to analyze
fracture attributes precisely and effectively. The results from this
work could provide insights and guidance for the field application
of SC-CO2 fracturing in unconventional oil and gas resources.