The objectives of this study are to compare the chemical properties of organic matter (OM) in alkaline extracts of turkey litter compost, source-separated organic compost and biosolid pellets, and to validate the use of humic acids (HA) for analyzing the functionality, i.e., the ability to complex with nutrients, of OM. The humic fractions, including humic acids (HA), fulvic acids (FA) and alkaline non-dissolved fraction (humin), were isolated either with NaOH or Na 4 P 2 O 7 (PyroP) and the chemical properties were analyzed by solid-state 13 C NMR spectroscopy. The study showed that the proportions of each functional group of the combination of HA, FA and humin were essentially identical to that of their HCl-treated original materials, except for a lower recovery of O-alkyl groups. Although the yield of HA extracted with PyroP was lower than that with NaOH, their spectral characteristics were not significantly different. The functionality of the OM, assuming a correlation with the sum of the proportions of carboxyl and phenolic groups, was higher in both HA and FA than that in humin. Based on the proportion and functionality of the HA in the OM, we conclude that the use of HA extracted with either NaOH or PyroP is valid for studies of OM functionality. The study also shows that the functionality and stability of OM are highly source dependent. We predict that amendments of the more humified turkey litter compost would have higher potential to increase SOM levels and retain nutrients compared to the source-separated organic compost and biosolid pellets.