Gibbsite (α-Al(OH) 3 ) transformation into layered double hydroxides, such as lithium aluminum hydroxide dihydrate (LiAl-LDH), is generally thought to occur by solidstate intercalation of Li + , in part because of the intrinsic structural similarities in the quasi-2D octahedral Al 3+ frameworks of these two materials. However, in caustic environments where gibbsite solubility is high relative to LiAl-LDH, a dissolutionreprecipitation pathway is conceptually enabled, proceeding via precipitation of tetrahedral (T d ) aluminate anions (Al(OH) 4 − ) at concentrations held below 150 mM by rapid LiAl-LDH nucleation and growth. In this case, the relative importance of solid-state versus solution pathways is unknown because it requires in situ techniques that can distinguish Al 3+ in solution and in the solid phase (gibbsite and LiAl-LDH), simultaneously. Here, we examine this transformation in partially deuterated LiOH solutions, using multinuclear, magic angle spinning, and high field nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy ( 27 Al and 6 Li MAS NMR), with supporting X-ray diffraction and scanning electron microscopy. In situ 27 Al MAS NMR captured the emergence and decline of metastable aluminate ions, consistent with dissolution of gibbsite and formation of LiAl-LDH by precipitation. High field, ex situ 6 Li NMR of the the progressively reacted solids resolved an O h Li + resonance that narrowed during the transformation. This is likely due to increasing local order in LiAl-LDH, correlating well with observations in high field, ex situ 27 Al MAS NMR spectra, where a comparatively narrow LiAl-LDH O h 27 Al resonance emerges upfield of gibbsite resonances. No intermediate pentahedral Al 3+ is resolvable. Quantification of aluminate ion concentrations suggests a prominent role for the solution pathway in this system, a finding that could help improve strategies for manipulating Al 3+ concentrations in complex caustic waste streams, such as those being proposed to treat the high-level nuclear waste stored at the U.S. Department of Energy's Hanford Nuclear Reservation in Washington State, USA.