Barriers to yoga therapy as an add-on treatment for schizophrenia in India

Abstract

Aim:To describe the possible barriers to yoga therapy for patients with schizophrenia in India.Materials and Methods:In a randomized control trial at NIMHANS, patients with schizophrenia (on stable doses of antipsychotics, 18–60 years of age, with a Clinical Global Impression-Severity score of 3 or more) were randomized into one of three limbs: Yoga therapy, physical exercise and waitlist. Of 857 patients screened, 392 (45.7%) patients were found eligible for the study. Among them, 223 (56.8%) declined to take part in the trial. The primary reasons for declining were analyzed.Results:The primary reasons for declining were (a) distance from the center (n=83; 37.2%); (b) no one to accompany them for training (n=25; 11.2%); (c) busy work schedule (n=21, 9.4%); (d) unwilling to come for one month (n=11; 4.9%), (e) not willing for yoga therapy (n=9, 4.0%); (f) personal reasons (n=3, 1.3%); (g) religious reasons (n=1, 0.4%). In 70 patients (31.6%), no reasons were ascribed. No patient refused citing research nature of the intervention as a reason.Conclusion:More than half of the patients eligible for yoga did not consent to the study. Logistic factors, such as the need for daily training under supervision in a specialized center for long periods, are the most important barriers that prevent patients with schizophrenia from receiving yoga therapy. Alternative models/schedules that are patient-friendly must be explored to reach the benefit of yoga to patients with schizophrenia.

Mindful yoga as an adjunct treatment for forensic inpatients: a preliminary evaluation

“…Despite being time-demanding, attrition rate was low (N = 6/32) contrary to time demands seen as a barrier in undertaking yoga research with schizophrenia inpatients and outpatients (Baspure et al, 2012;Duraiswamy, Thirthalli, Nagendra, & Gangadhar, 2007). Low attrition rate in this study may partially be attributable to the accessibility of the venue (close proximity) and participants' enjoyment in attending this programme.…”

Yoga-based intervention in patients with somatoform disorders: an open label trial

“…However, more men (57%) agreed to be part of the study. One of the reasons may be the difficulty in travelling on their own to attend the sessions as expressed by many women (Baspure, Jagannathan, Kumar, Varambally, & Thirthalli, 2012;Dayananda, Ilavarasu, Rajesh, & Babu, 2014). In this study, 64 subjects consented; however, only 34 completed the study, indicating a high dropout rate.…”

Yoga and epilepsy: What do patients perceive?

“…The primary one seems to be logistic difficulties in coming for yoga regularly such as travelling long distances to the yoga center, lack of family support, financial problems, time constraint, and so on. [21]…”

“…[1213141516] There are a few studies which have elicited the patient's knowledge and attitude towards yoga and related it to service delivery. [1718192021] However, the perception of benefit in different medical conditions varies.…”