Battle of the bots: a comparison of the standard da Vinci and the da Vinci Surgical Skills Simulator in surgical skills acquisition

Abstract

Virtual reality simulators are increasingly used to gain robotic surgical skills. This study compared use of the da Vinci Surgical Skills Simulator (dVSSS) to the standard da Vinci (SdV) robot for skills acquisition in a prospective randomized study. Residents from urology, gynecology, and general surgery programs performed three virtual reality tasks (thread the ring, ring rail, and tubes) on the dvSSS. Participants were then randomized to one of the two study groups (dVSSS and SdV). Each participant then practiced on either the dVSSS or the SdV (depending on randomization) for 30 min per week over a 4-week time period. The dVSSS arm was not permitted to practice ring rail (due to no similar practice scenario available for the SdV group). Following 4 weeks of practice, participants performed the same three virtual reality tasks and the results were recorded and compared to baseline. Overall and percent improvement were recorded for all participants from pre-test to post-test. Two-way ANOVA analyses were used to compare the dVSSS and SdV groups and three tasks. Initially, 30 participants were identified and enrolled in the study. Randomization resulted in 15 participants in each arm. During the course of the study, four participants were unable to complete all tasks and practice sessions and were, therefore, excluded. This resulted in a total of 26 participants (15 in the dVSSS group and 11 in the SdV group) who completed the study. Overall total improvement score was found to be 23.23 and 23.48 for the SdV and dVSSS groups, respectively (p = 0.9245). The percent improvement was 60 and 47 % for the SdV and dVSSS groups respectively, which was a statistically significant difference between the two groups and three tasks. Practicing on the standard da Vinci is comparable to practicing on the da Vinci simulator for acquiring robotic surgical skills. In spite of several potential advantages, the dVSSS arm performed no better than the SdV arm in the final assessment of participant scores. Our findings indicate that both the SdV and dVSSS can be beneficial to residents in improving their robotic surgery skills.

The emerging role for robotics in cholecystectomy: the dawn of a new era?

“…The da Vinci Skills Simulator ® has been shown to provide similar training for the same physical skills on a standard robotic system (44). As the emphasis on simulation changes from simple task performance to procedure-based duplication of clinical scenarios, this will further reduce or eliminate the learning curve associated with the technology and improve operative safety.…”

Cognitive training for robotic surgery: a chance to optimize surgical training? A pilot study

“…The provided virtual reality (VR) environment enables novice robotic surgeons to practice surgical skills without compromising patient safety; consequently, such simulation training has become an established and reliable component in surgical training on the da Vinci operating system [21]. Generally, complex procedures of robotic-assisted surgery (RAS) based on different motor skills, technical knowledge, cognitive skills, and psychomotoric skills are mandatory [22][23][24].…”

Application of a Perception Neuron® System in Simulation-Based Surgical Training

“…The traditional apprenticeship-based model of surgical education is increasingly being replaced by education using mannequins, cadavers, training boxes, and virtual reality simulators [13,18,19,20,21,22]. Research in this area has gradually moved from introducing simulation training to identifying the education method that most effectively teaches the requisite surgical skills.…”