Bayesian Model-Updating Using Features of Modal Data: Application to the Metsovo Bridge

Abstract

A Bayesian framework is presented for finite element model-updating using experimental modal data. A novel likelihood formulation is proposed regarding the inclusion of the mode shapes, based on a probabilistic treatment of the MAC value between the model predicted and experimental mode shapes. The framework is demonstrated by performing model-updating for the Metsovo bridge using a reduced high-fidelity finite element model. Experimental modal identification methods are used in order to extract the modal characteristics of the bridge from ambient acceleration time histories obtained from field measurements exploiting a network of reference and roving sensors. The Transitional Markov Chain Monte Carlo algorithm is used to perform the model updating by drawing samples from the posterior distribution of the model parameters. The proposed framework yields reasonable uncertainty bounds for the model parameters, insensitive to the redundant information contained in the measured data due to closely spaced sensors. In contrast, conventional Bayesian formulations which use probabilistic models to characterize the components of the discrepancy vector between the measured and model-predicted mode shapes result in unrealistically thin uncertainty bounds for the model parameters for a large number of sensors.

Methodology Maps for Model-Based Sensor-Data Interpretation to Support Civil-Infrastructure Management

“…BMU is best employed for analyzing laboratory experiments conducted in controlled environments (Prajapat and Ray-Chaudhuri 2016;Zhang et al, 2017;Rappel et al, 2018Rappel et al, , 2020Mohamedou et al, 2019;Rappel and Beex 2019) to reduce bias from modelling assumptions. BMU is also appropriate for analyzing large-scale systems when the physics-based models developed are unbiased approximations of reality as is often the case for mechanicalengineering applications (Abdallah et al, 2017;Avendaño-Valencia and Chatzi 2017;Hara et al, 2017;Argyris et al, 2020;Cooper et al, 2020;Patsialis et al, 2020).…”

Structural and load parameter estimation of a real‐world reinforced concrete slab bridge using measurements and Bayesian statistics

“…Often, the dynamic response of the bridges is used either without considering uncertainties in the inference [5][6][7] or by adopting a probabilistic approach. 4,8 For example, Teughels and De Roeck 7 used ambient vibrations recorded by accelerometers to detect and quantify the damage of a three-span prestressed concrete bridge (bridge Z24) in Switzerland. The damage in the bridge was caused by settlement of one of the supporting piers.…”

Statistical model-based optimization for damage extent quantification

“…The current paper focuses on the impact of the uncertainty of the estimated modal parameters in the model optimization, and most particularly for the MAC estimate, whose statistical properties in this context were never investigated, but only inferred in Bayesian updating [50]. In general, the MAC can be viewed as the inner product of two Gaussian unit vectors.…”