Bayesian uncertainty assessment of flood predictions in ungauged urban basins for conceptual rainfall-runoff models

Abstract

Urbanization and the resulting land-use change strongly affect the water cycle and runoff-processes in watersheds. Unfortunately, small urban watersheds, which are most affected by urban sprawl, are mostly ungauged. This makes it intrinsically difficult to assess the consequences of urbanization. Most of all, it is unclear how to reliably assess the predictive uncertainty given the structural deficits of the applied models. In this study, we therefore investigate the uncertainty of flood predictions in ungauged urban basins from structurally uncertain rainfall-runoff models. To this end, we suggest a procedure to explicitly account for input uncertainty and model structure deficits using Bayesian statistics with a continuous-time autoregressive error model. In addition, we propose a concise procedure to derive prior parameter distributions from base data and successfully apply the methodology to an urban catchment in Warsaw, Poland. Based on our results, we are able to demonstrate that the autoregressive error model greatly helps to meet the statistical assumptions and to compute reliable prediction intervals. In our study, we found that predicted peak flows were up to 7 times higher than observations. This was reduced by 150% with Bayesian updating, using only a few discharge measurements. In addition, our analysis suggests that imprecise rainfall information and model structure deficits contribute mostly to the total prediction uncertainty. In the future, flood predictions in ungauged basins will become more important due to ongoing urbanization as well as anthropogenic and climatic changes. Thus, providing reliable measures of uncertainty is crucial to support decision making

Prediction of water discharge and sediment in teak forested area using artificial neural network model

“…Oleh sebab itu diperlukan model sederhana yang mampu memrediksi hasil air secara akurat dengan data yang sederhana dan mudah diperoleh. Prediksi tersebut dapat dilakukan dengan pemodelan, baik dengan menyusun model baru maupun mengaplikasikan model yang sudah tersedia disertai validasi sesuai dengan kondisi DAS yang spesifik (Sikorska et al, 2012). Model merupakan penyederhanaan dari realitas yang kompleks (Voinov, 2008).…”

Model bias and complexity – Understanding the effects of structural deficits and input errors on runoff predictions

“…Instead, parametric uncertainty appears to be the only type of model uncertainty that has been analyzed (e.g., Freni et al, 2009). Few recent exceptions have been the investigations of Sun and BertrandKrajewski (2013), Sikorska et al (2012), and Del Giudice et al (2013). While the first study estimated rainfall errors but assumed no structural deficits, the others implicitly considered the combined impact of structural and input inadequacies by using autoregressive output error models.…”

“…First, these error sources can be the dominant cause of predictive uncertainty (Renard et al, 2011). Second, neglecting structural and input errors usually lead to autocorrelated residuals and therefore biased parameter estimates, as well as underestimation of uncertainty (Neumann and Gujer, 2008;Sikorska et al, 2012). Third, we are interested in understanding how much a better model structure can improve the precision and accuracy of our predictions.…”

“…Among the simplest continuous-time models are lumped reservoir models (e.g. Breinholt et al, 2012;Sikorska et al, 2012). These parsimonious simulators (i.e.…”

Uncertainty of Deardorff’s soil moisture model based on continuous TDR measurements for sandy loam soil

“…On the other hand, insight into moisture profiles was attempted from surface measurements, and given in: (Arya et al, 1983;Camillo and Schmugge, 1983;Entekhabi et al, 1994;Jackson, 1980). Independent of the applied technique, the gained knowledge on the soil wetness status is indispensable for catchment runoff modelling, that usually requires complex models with spatially distributed parameters, having prescribed uncertainty ranges (Marcinkowski et al, 2013;Sikorska et al, 2012). Among those parameters, the soil water content is one of the most important to trigger surface runoff (Brandyk and Majewski, 2013;Chormański, 2012;Deardorff, 1977).…”