Supramolecular peptide−drug conjugates (sPDCs) are prepared by covalent attachment of a drug moiety to a peptide motif programmed for one-dimensional self-assembly, with subsequent physical entanglement of these fibrillar structures enabling formation of nanofibrous hydrogels. This class of prodrug materials presents an attractive platform for mass-efficient and sitespecific delivery of therapeutic agents using a discrete, singlecomponent molecular design. However, a continued challenge in sPDC development is elucidating relationships between supramolecular interactions in their drug and peptide domains and the resultant impacts of these domains on assembly outcomes and material properties. Inclusion of a saturated alkyl segment alongside the prodrug in the hydrophobic domain of sPDCs could relieve some of the necessity for ordered, prodrug−produg interactions. Accordingly, nine sPDCs are prepared here to iterate the design variables of amino acid sequence and hydrophobic prodrug−alkyl block design. All molecules spontaneously formed hydrogels under physiological conditions, indicating a less hindered thermodynamic path to self-assembly relative to previous prodrug-only designs. However, material studies on the supramolecular arrangement, formation, and mechanical properties of the resultant sPDC hydrogels as well as their drug release profiles showed complex relationships between the hydrophobic and peptide domains in the formation and function of the resulting assemblies. Together, these results indicate that sPDC material properties are intrinsically linked to holistic molecular design with coupled contributions from their prodrug and peptide domains in directing properties of the emergent materials.