Food-borne pathogens are a serious challenge in food handling, processing, and packaging systems. The growth of microbial biofilms on food handling surfaces further complicates the management of the microbial contamination of food. Microorganisms within biofilms are difficult to eradicate with chemical disinfectants, with an increased likelihood of survival and the subsequent contamination of food. Therefore, a biofilm approach is needed in food safety and hygiene studies. Since many factors, such as strain, cell density, surface type and texture, environmental stress, and so forth, can affect biofilm formation and disinfectant efficacy, we evaluated the responses of biofilms formed by three food-borne bacterial pathogens on eight hard surfaces to seven chemical disinfectants. The three bacteria showed different capacities to colonize the surfaces. Similarly, chemical disinfectants also varied in efficacy, on surfaces and with pathogen species. One-, two-, and three-way interactions of strain, surface, and disinfectant were observed. The results generated demonstrate that the fine-tuning of sanitization strategies along the food production, processing, and packaging chain can be achieved in specific scenarios by accounting for two- and three-way interactions among bacteria, surface, and disinfectant.